After 14 Years it sinks in: Maybe US is just not Good at Asian Counter-Insurgency
http://www.juancole.com/2016/02/after-14-years-it-sinks-in-maybe-us-is-just-not-good-at-asian-counter-insurgency.html
After 14 Years it sinks in: Maybe US is just not Good at Asian Counter-Insurgency
By contributors | Feb. 8, 2016
By Tom Engelhardt
Heres my twenty-first-century rule of thumb about this country: if you have to say it over and over, it probably aint so. Which is why Id think twice every time were told how exceptional or indispensable the United States is. For someone like me who can still remember a moment when Americans assumed that was so, but no sitting president, presidential candidate, or politician felt you had to say the obvious, such lines reverberate with defensiveness. They seem to incorporate other voices you can almost hear whispering that were ever less exceptional, more dispensable, no longer (to quote the greatest of them all by his own estimate) the greatest. In this vein, consider a commonplace line running around Washington (as it has for years): the U.S. military is the finest fighting force in the history of the world. Uh, folks, if thats so, then why the hell cant it win a damn thing 14-plus years later?
If you dont mind a little what-if history lesson, its just possible that events might have turned out differently and, instead of repeating that finest fighting force stuff endlessly, our leaders might actually believe it. After all, in the wake of the 9/11 attacks, it took the Bush administration only a month to let the CIA, special forces advisers, and the U.S. Air Force loose against the Taliban and Osama bin Ladens supporters in Afghanistan. The results were crushing. The first moments of what that administration would grandiloquently (and ominously) bill as a global war on terror were, destructively speaking, glorious.
~snip~
The U.S. military and its Afghan proxies, if you remember, believed that they had trapped Osama bin Laden and his al-Qaeda fighters somewhere in the mountainous Tora Bora region. If the U.S. had concentrated all its resources on him at that moment, its hard to believe that he wouldnt have been in American custody or dead sooner rather than later. And that would have been that. The U.S. military could have gone home victorious. The Taliban, along with bin Laden, would have been history. Stop the cameras there and what a tale of triumph would surely have been told.
Shoulda, woulda, coulda.