Religion
Related: About this forumJust What Kind of Revolution is Francis Calling For?
http://www.religiondispatches.org/archive/atheologies/7217/just_what_kind_of_revolution_is_francis_calling_for/July 30, 2013
By MANUEL A. VÁSQUEZ AND SILVIA ALVES FERNANDES
Franciss visit to Brazil has generated an enormous outpouring of emotion and fervor. From the moment he stepped out of the plane he was been mobbed by throngs of excited followers straining to see and touch him. Francis has relished the opportunity to get close to the people which, among other things, has given his security detail veritable nightmares. What accounts for this tumultuous reception, particularly in the wake of so much popular frustration and anger expressed in street protests just a couple of weeks ago?
Judging by the testimony of many Brazilians who flocked to see Francis, it has a great deal to do with his impressive capacity to express empathy, care and intimacy, a capacity eloquently conveyed through speeches and symbols, such as his address upon arrival in which he humbly declared: I have learned that to have access to the Brazilian people, it is necessary to enter through the door of their immense heart. So, allow me that in this hour I may delicately knock on this door. I ask permission to enter and spend this week with you.
More importantly, Francis expresses a genuine embodied desire to be present, lowering the window of the car transporting him amid the multitude, kissing babies, hugging people with disabilities, walking the streets of Varginha in the cold rain. With a self-effacing humor, he told the crowd, When I first decided to come to Brazil, I wanted to knock on every door and say good morning . . . ask for a glass of water, drink a coffee but not a shot of cachaça [a popular hard liquor].
Without essentializing Brazilian culture, anthropologists such as Sérgio Buarque de Holanda and Roberto DaMatta have observed that Brazilians value very highly informality, the personal touch, the affective force and cordiality of friendship and kinship ties, and the intimacy of home as a space of human warmth, authenticity and safety against the competitive, impersonal, and cold world of the street. Drawing from his own background, Franciss sermons and actions strongly resonate with these Brazilian habits of the heart, as sociologist Robert Bellah put it, particularly at time of widespread economic uncertainty and persistent social inequalities. One ecstatic young Catholic from Varginha put it well: I think this pope is very different . . . . He hugs people. Hes from the people. This pope is a Brazilian.
more at link
customerserviceguy
(25,183 posts)but as long as it ends up with more people drinking the Catholic Kool-Aid, he'll be happy.
cbayer
(146,218 posts)I thought the article was an interesting perspective from a South American POV.
snot
(10,529 posts)Francis has said a lot of hopeful things and made a lot of hopeful symbolic gestures. It's not yet clear how much he'll actually change the system.
cbayer
(146,218 posts)Is he effectively paving the way for change or will this all just turn out to be symbolic?
At any rate, whatever it is, it apparently resonated with a lot of Brazilians.
MissMarple
(9,656 posts)Less dogma, more love and respect.
cbayer
(146,218 posts)But he didn't rise this high in the hierarchy without being pretty good at politics as well.
We shall see.
longship
(40,416 posts)(And you know I am that.)
I am surprised by the new Pope, as many are. But I am simultaneously jaded by the actions of the previous popes. (And I would go back centuries for that argument.)
In my life, other than John XXIII, I have seen no other willing to reform. All the others seem to want to deform, to seemingly want to regress.
The Vatican has long since given up what I would call Christianity. They seem to only wish to preserve their existing misogynistic hierarchy.
Shit! The church, even in its most recent liberal instance, is still centuries behind the times.
But at least the pope said that gays aren't necessarily condemned to Hell. One wonders what the caveats might be.
Thank you very little, Mr. Pope.
cbayer
(146,218 posts)I have never been a fan of the RCC and their hierarchy, including the popes.
But they are here to stay, imo, and even a minor turn in the right direction gives me a glimmer of hope.
They could be such a powerful organization for good. I'm not optimistic, but I would like to see them at least stop perpetuating bad.
It's a really tough one for me. I don't want to be in the position of defending him or his institutions.
On the other hand, my son is about to marry into a very catholic family and will most likely convert.
It is for him, his new family and his children that I hang on to a shred of hope for the RCC as an institution.
And for all the other good catholics on this earth.
You are such a dear and I feel so fortunate to have you as a friend.
Hope all is well.
skepticscott
(13,029 posts)But you ARE in a position of defending the pope and his institutions. You do it rather regularly, in fact, along with the rest of your little clique of apologists. It's not in your nature to do otherwise.