2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumWho Hillary was quoting in 1996 - this is important.
When Hillary was talking about superpredators, she was quoting John J. DiIulio, Jr..
He was invited to the Clinton White House to help them come up with a solution to youth crime in 1995.
That happened because he came up with a popular (in the media) theory that a large chunk of "inner city" youth were basically becoming "monsters". Particularly the black youth.
" DiIulio) is impatient with those who believe that treating black criminals harshly is somehow inimical to the interests of blacks in general."
http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1995-05-08/news/1995128167_1_black-crime-diiulio-silent-majority
This idea was promoted by DiIulio in dozens of articles in national papers and most noteably in the book Body Count
That book starts with the premise that the Reagan-Bush drug war "the most successful attack on a serious social problem in the last quarter-century," and goes downhill fast, predicting that a new strain of monster children were preying on society, and a large group of them were about to be unleashed... so we better start locking up juveniles - and FAST!
Criminals, especially the pathological variety our family-less culture has been producing in the last generation or so, cannot be rehabilitated, reformed or saved, Mr. DiIulio believes. They are the bitter fruit of loveless, abusive unions of unsocialized people. Having received nothing, they are without human compassion. They kill and rape without mercy or remorse. They can only be incapacitated by prison.
..first, he would reform the criminal justice system so that predatory criminals, adult and juvenile, would stay in jail for a very long time.
This wasn't about gangs either... in fact he repeatedly said that superpredators looked up to gangs, or tried to emulate drug dealers... they weren't either.. they were just inhuman monsters.
From the NYTs:
"Then a professor at Princeton, married and the father of three young children, Mr. DiIulio became a prominent voice in the world of criminology with his superpredator theory. But although a respected academic, he was suddenly questioned by peers, who said he seemed to be providing cover for what they considered partisan politics.
''He became a sensationalist, a simplistic analyst who rather toadied to that point of view,'' said Norval Morris, professor of law at the University of Chicago and co-editor of the Oxford History of the Prison. ''He should have known better than that.''
It was shortly afterward, Mr. DiIulio said, while praying at Mass on Palm Sunday in 1996, that he had an ''epiphany -- a conversion of heart, a conversion of mind,'' that changed him from a complacent Roman Catholic to one who ''took his religion seriously.''
He was sitting in a church in New Jersey that day, ''and it just became crystal clear to me,'' the 42-year-old Mr. DiIulio said in the interview at Penn, where he is a professor of government policy. ''God had given me a Rolodex, good will and a passion that was sometimes misdirected, and I knew that for the rest of my life I would work on prevention, on helping bring caring, responsible adults to wrap their arms around these kids.''
It's well that he had this conversion, because his peers smelled a rat, a big stupid rat:
Soon, what had been his chief theory was discredited: instead of rising, the rate of juvenile crime dropped by more than half.
''His prediction wasn't just wrong, it was exactly the opposite,'' said Franklin E. Zimring, professor of law at the University of California at Berkeley and director of the university's Earl Warren Legal Institute. ''His theories on superpredators were utter madness.''
http://www.nytimes.com/2001/02/09/us/as-ex-theorist-on-young-superpredators-bush-aide-has-regrets.html
DiIulio was invited to the White House at the height of his fame, so to speak, in 1995. Bill and Hillary had a three and a half hour meeting with him and others about youth crime ("President Clinton took copious notes and asked lots of questions, but nothing was accomplished."
He also repeatedly made the suggestion that nothing could be done - aside from locking up the monsters ("No one in academia is a bigger fan of incarceration than I am." - except encouraging them all to find god. No seriously. That was his only suggestion. Lock up the kids or help them find god so they can claim back a bit of their lost humanity.
Well, ok - that's not QUITE true:
Finally, Mr. DiIulio proves better than anyone in the public debate on crime that there is no inconsistency between being tough on criminals and looking at root causes. Many conservatives are dismissive of root-causes talk because they think it amounts to justification for criminality.
It needn't, and in Mr. DiIulio's hands, it doesn't. The plain fact is that of the most vicious criminals we produce, nearly all come from the same kind of environments: no father, an incompetent, abusive and frequently drug-addicted mother, and a chaotic, violent neighborhood. If the existing child welfare laws were merely enforced properly, the children who are being abused and neglected at ages 2, 3 or 4 could be removed from their "homes" and either placed for adoption or put in group homes. By that step, we would prevent an ongoing crime (the abuse of that child) as well as thwart the creation of one more rapacious criminal.
That article was published BEFORE he was invited to the White House, as were numerous other article just like it. That's the man Bill invited to help him solve youth crime and that's the man Hillary quoted months later. Chillingly, in the weeks before Hillary now infamously uttered the word superpredator, DiIulio wrote, "By my estimate, we will probably need to incarcerate at least 150,000 juvenile criminals in the years just ahead".
And Bill did just that.
More links:
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1995-12-15/news/9512150046_1_crime-talking-bomb/5
http://www.amazon.com/Body-Count-William-J-Bennett/dp/0614198879
http://www.brookings.edu/research/testimony/1996/02/28crime-diiulio
libtodeath
(2,888 posts)It sickens me to see the obvious dog whistles defended here.
seaotter
(576 posts)tk2kewl
(18,133 posts)seaotter
(576 posts)She knew the "code" and it fit what she wanted to convey, and whom she wanted to convey it to.
EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)it was repeating something that was in the media which was aimed at "inner city" "monster" children that needed to be treated harshly by the police and locked up a long time. No saving them.
tk2kewl
(18,133 posts)EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)tk2kewl
(18,133 posts)azmom
(5,208 posts)FreakinDJ
(17,644 posts)UglyGreed
(7,661 posts)EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)I actually meant to include that in the OP!!
UglyGreed
(7,661 posts)I found it was good summary of what can happen when the media and our leaders fall for what I would call propaganda.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)this philosophy? Are they teaching this shit in police academies?
UglyGreed
(7,661 posts)that plus our nation has become more and more militarized. I had new neighbors move in and two of them are NYPD. One was recently retired and the other is in their early thirties and pretty new to the force. One a man and the younger one was a woman. When I spent an evening with them I'll tell you I was shocked about what they had to say.
loyalsister
(13,390 posts)in law, SC rulings, and US culture.
The eugenics movement targeted blacks as they were intentionally over-represented among the people judged as unfit to reproduce. Once eugenics was discredited they found a back up plan.
The rhetoric is the same. The "solutions" are deplorably racist.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)both Clintons to this theory is absolutely sickening. We think the Trump might be turning us into Nazis but this theory just seems to be a kinder and gentler method.
loyalsister
(13,390 posts)This agenda to enforce white supremacy is so ugly and so persistant. It's as if there are people in think tanks saying, "since slavery is out, how about putting together chain gangs?"
Progressives step in and say, "since they are mistreated in prison and their lives generally suck maybe it would be better if we are compassionate enough to just prevent their existance."
Since that didn't work out it's back to plan A. I am glad to see people calling her out. This is the experience she brags about and it should also serve as a cautionary tale of how people have been exploited by the Clintons- from mass incarceration to firewalls.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)a victim of eugenics - not from a racial stand point - from the issue of mental illness. TPTB were determined to create a super-race long before Hitler ever even thought about it and it started here in this country.
We need to win this election and we need to fight for sanity when ever we can.
loyalsister
(13,390 posts)Eugenics was funded by the Koch's of the day- Carnegie's and Rockefellers.
We have to pull together and especially support the activists who are challenging white supremacy. They give me hope.
EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)did you know that the foundation of planned parenthood was kinda based on eugenics... the founder of it was obsessed with eugenics... as were most scientists at the time...
Even more disturbing though, is that the US government spent YEARS AND YEARS secretly sterilizing tens of thousands of poor and minority women... and that lasted up into the 1970s.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)have changed their goals. They are more interested in helping women now than in creating a master race.
Although I remember in the 60s that many minority groups did not trust them even then. Thought it was all about limiting the birth of POC. And unfortunately to some that is what it was all about.
EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)I just think it's interesting...
jwirr
(39,215 posts)it's so hard for people to really realise how recent this was as well... when we put men on the moon interracial marriage was still illegal in 13 states.
loyalsister
(13,390 posts)she was definitely flawed. Alexander Graham Bell was a big supporter, as well. They and many other progressives came to the movement in the name of compassion. Preventing people being born into poverty or disability was intended to reduce suffering.
I don't know how aware they were of the motives of the white supremacists they aligned themselves with. But, they are not absolved either way.
EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)it was official government policy - eugenics - all over the world... messed up stuff... :/
jwirr
(39,215 posts)stand up and be counted. And I am loving every moment of this campaign with Bernie and the young voters. We have finally go our spirit back.
Onward.
loyalsister
(13,390 posts)The young activists are pulling back the curtain and they may save us, yet!
EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)Uncle Joe
(58,364 posts)Thanks for the thread, EdwardBernays.
nenagh
(1,925 posts)Stunning to read something so dreadful...
Thank you for the OP.
earthside
(6,960 posts)Previously, he served as the first director of the White House Office of Faith-Based and Community Initiatives under President George W. Bush from early 2001 to August 2001. ...
He is also credited with coining, or at least popularizing, the term (and concept of) "superpredators" in reference to juvenile violent crime in the early 1990s.[4] Under this concept DiIulio and co-authors, William J. Bennett and John P. Walters, referred to America's youth as, "radically impulsive, [and] brutally remorseless youngsters..."[5]
This is the big, big problem with Hillary Clinton's candidacy -- the political baggage isn't just the scandals from the Clinton administration, it is her associations, what influenced her, what she advocated back then ... what she claims to believe today.
More and more theme of this graphic is going to be Hillary's undoing:
Paka
(2,760 posts)delrem
(9,688 posts)They are now, no shit, the only answer to all social justice problems.
Just don't ask them about economics. Or war. Economics and war don't count in Dem primary rhetoric.
bbgrunt
(5,281 posts)nadinbrzezinski
(154,021 posts)By the way stop and frisk... is one of it's children
EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)This system is so broken, and Americans are so overwhelmed by propaganda and know so little of their own history... well... these problems are long term and need honesty to be fixed... but we all need to be honest, especially our leaders.
nadinbrzezinski
(154,021 posts)and my city council. Chief dances, many of our local political readers are truly not knowledgeable on this. I mean they are not dancing, they have no clue.
EdwardBernays
(3,343 posts)I tell ya... I live in Ireland now and people are not EVER scared of the cops... criminals are I guess, but if you're doing nothing wrong you can shout at a cop all day and nothing ever happens.. cops are almost all neighbourhood based and for the most part all policing is very very local... walking and bikes... and importantly no guns.
It's amazing how much stress that removes from day to day life...
I grew up in the south and was harassed by cops, and had them threaten to plant drugs on me if I and me friend resisted an illegal search... scary shit... I also was arrested a few times as a teen - nothing serious, kids stuff - and I always had a gun pointed at me... as a kid... and was thrown to the ground and kneeled on while cuffed... one was for "trespassing".. I stepped over a cinder block wall to take a short cut... that kind of crap... and still guns out... very happy my kids won't know that fear.
Major Hogwash
(17,656 posts)I hope she drops out of the race soon and stops embarrassing the Democratic party.
zentrum
(9,865 posts)
even more horrifying than I knew.
Thanks for the information.
californiabernin
(421 posts)BernieforPres2016
(3,017 posts)Thanks for the post.
WillyT
(72,631 posts)Duppers
(28,125 posts)DiIulio guide their thinking.
I googled and read a bit more about him and did a few more of these...