Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Doctor Jack

(3,072 posts)
Wed Sep 14, 2016, 07:34 PM Sep 2016

Poll: Michigan Trump 47% Clinton 45%

Ok....not really, I just love a sense of symmetry. You see 4 years ago, I posted a thread with the same title here. It was after the first debate, Obama was being hammered by the media and the polls pulled into a romney lead. The people here were in full on panic mode because for a few days, Romney was barely ahead. We still had about 6 weeks until the election and everyone was already declaring Mittens the winner. Why post such a jarring tread title? Perhaps a bit of petty revenge for all of the worrywarts polluting the community with extreme negatively but more to do with the old trick of slapping someone that is hysterical to get them to focus.

So lets focus and get some perspective before you hit the alert button. We have a few bad polls for our side today. A tie in Nevada and Florida, and Trump up by 5 in Ohio. I might believe Nevada and Florida as a tie right now but I doubt the Ohio +5 just because it is such a sudden, and jarring result but irregardless we need to keep a few things in mind. First, off the Trump surge as of late puts cheeto face in his best position in a long time, which is still really bad. Around the low 200's for his EV count. After all of these ebbs and flows in the polls, where he has never even pulled into a tie, do we really expect that all of a sudden, because Hillary got pneumonia, that he will surge past her? It is difficult, when being bombarded by doom and gloom to think that the worst possible scenario has come to life. 4 years ago, after the first presidential debate, it was easy to think "the debates have changed everything, romney looks like he is going to win." Then what happened, a week or two later, Obama was in the lead again and never looked back. Sure, 1 day of polling can be distressing. I remember back in May, when a slew of polls came out showing Trump suddenly ahead of Clinton in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Florida, feeling a bit of concern and frustration. So was the near tie they pulled into post-republican convention. You look at those results and say "how can anyone want this guy to be president?". But throughout the ebbs and flows of the campaign, even when it seemed at its darkest, the clown quickly faded back. The problem really is fundamentals. The demographics of this country just don't work for Trump's candidacy. Sure, today, we have articles talking about how all of a sudden, young adults, hispanics, blacks have tuned out of the election and Clinton's hope of holding the Obama coalition together is in ruins. All of a sudden, for no reason. Last week, it was fine. But this week, nope, gone.

This is the problem when something defies explanation. You can look at a poll from Ohio suddenly showing Trump up by 5 and be dumbfounded or think "there is no way that minority voters suddenly don't care about the election." And there is a good reason to be dumbfounded because none of that really makes sense. Sensational headlines are good at generating clicks but without an explanation or a blantely obvious cause, it makes no sense in the broader context. And maybe that is because its a fluke or a transient period before everything regresses to the mean. I'm sure, after being whipped into a panic today, the idea that Trump is suddenly ahead in Michigan seemed realistic, even though it too would make no sense.

The point is, its important to take a broad prospective, not look at one day of polling in isolation and point to one meaningless event, like Hillary getting a little weak kneed over the weekend, as the defining moments of the campaign. Remember, this is a long game. A poll from ohio in September, the media bashing Hillary for a few days, Trump giving Dr. Oz a piece of paper to prove he is the picture of health, these are brief moments. In a day or a week, they won't matter. Long term issues are what matter and long term polls readings are what is important. Elections don't change on a dime, that is just an illusion created by the media. Hillary has been consistently ahead since June 2015 in the polls and she is still ahead today. Its not a tie and Trump isn't ahead. That too, when looked at objectively, is an illusion.

Sure, we could be living in the world of the worst case scenario and Trump could win in November. Its not impossible but its also very unlikely. It could rain tomorrow and it could just keep raining until your neighborhood is under 40 feet of water. Or it could just rain for 1 day. Don't let the media suck you in. We had a bad day of poll numbers. Maybe Trump is going to keep gaining and win easily. Or maybe its just a bad day.

10 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Poll: Michigan Trump 47% Clinton 45% (Original Post) Doctor Jack Sep 2016 OP
And I thought I was a merciless bastard! Loki Liesmith Sep 2016 #1
Its not about being merciless Doctor Jack Sep 2016 #3
it was still damn funny Loki Liesmith Sep 2016 #4
Who is the pollster? Charles Bukowski Sep 2016 #2
Murkie and Overa Loki Liesmith Sep 2016 #5
A much-needed splash of cold water, thank you. Chichiri Sep 2016 #6
Thank you for helping me sleep better tonight. skylucy Sep 2016 #7
False comparison. Obama was/is much better at politics than Hillary radius777 Sep 2016 #8
I agree. zenabby Sep 2016 #10
gave you rec 10! Still, let's hope for a real masterfully run campaign by HRC with Obama's help the Divine Discontent Sep 2016 #9

Doctor Jack

(3,072 posts)
3. Its not about being merciless
Wed Sep 14, 2016, 07:43 PM
Sep 2016

Its about proving a point. We go through the same thing every 4 years. I made roughly this same thread 4 years ago, under very similar circumstances and look at what happened. The fundamentals of the race didn't change, everything went back to how it had been for most of the election, and Obama won.

Oh and a lot of people completely forgot that this shit happens all the time in presidential elections.

radius777

(3,635 posts)
8. False comparison. Obama was/is much better at politics than Hillary
Thu Sep 15, 2016, 12:47 AM
Sep 2016

so him being tied or behind was never such a big deal, given his political skill and ability to come back.

He ran a much better campaign, had a clearer/tougher message, had better surrogates in the media, created more enthusiasm, doesn't make dumb mistakes, etc.

And Romney/Ryan ticket was a much stronger ticket than the fascist tea party clowns Trump/Pence, so it would make sense they would/should be closer in the polls.

I love Hillary, supported her even in 2008, but this is not a good campaign she is running against a historically weak candidate she should be destroying.

Her campaign team (Podesta, Mook, Fallon) sucks, and are nothing like the team either Bill Clinton (Carville, Begala, Stephanopolus) or Obama (Plouffe, Axelrod) had, who were much sharper and tougher in driving the narrative.

zenabby

(364 posts)
10. I agree.
Thu Sep 15, 2016, 03:06 PM
Sep 2016

But I also feel that this is related to misogyny and the "Clinton machine" narrative from long ago, and there's not much she can do - unless the media gives her some love.

Divine Discontent

(21,056 posts)
9. gave you rec 10! Still, let's hope for a real masterfully run campaign by HRC with Obama's help the
Thu Sep 15, 2016, 02:58 PM
Sep 2016

final 50 days...

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Poll: Michigan Trump 47% ...