2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumWhat Trump did tonight was half Gish gallop, half Palin 'answering the question I want'.
We've all likely seen Sarah Palin asked a question and provide a completely unrelated (and canned/rehersed) answer. Trump did this over and over tonight and, to the credit of the debate moderators, was often redirected to the original question.
His other tactic was the Gish Gallop, which involves planting rhetorical 'flags' all over the debate stage, in hopes that Hillary would have to spend all of her energy debunking his B.S. She did not fall for this tactic.
Between Hillary and the moderators, he was largely constrained to his box of B.S. and lost the debate on both style and substance.
More on the Gish Gallop here-
http://blogs.bu.edu/pbokulic/2013/11/18/gish-gallop-fallacy-of-the-day/
The Gish Gallop is the tactic of snowing your opponent under a mountain of supposed pieces of evidence or problem cases and claiming that the opponents inability to respond to this pile of evidence shows that your side is right. This tactic counts as a fallacy because its effectiveness doesnt depend on presenting arguments that are right or even well-supported. Quantity is offered as a substitute for quality.
C_U_L8R
(45,002 posts)Trump wasn't even answering his own canned talking points.
His logic is splintered and he didn't offer a single coherent idea.
We are all dumber for listening to him.
Snarkoleptic
(5,997 posts)It describes the Gish/Palin alloy.
R B Garr
(16,954 posts)with a microphone.
Snarkoleptic
(5,997 posts)Fox, Drudge, Alex Jone and the comments section of yahoo.com.
Tess49
(1,579 posts)I muted him, and listened to her. His shadowing/stalking was creepy.