Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

patrice

(47,992 posts)
Mon Feb 25, 2013, 02:37 AM Feb 2013

A piece of the cultural context for women's issues - Iphigenia: Women as accesories to nationalism

Iphigenia - directed by Mihalis Kakogiannis - 1977 - based on Euripedes' tragedy, "Iphigenia in Aulis."

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0076208/?ref_=sr_1

Because of the way that Rome conquered Greece, and a bunch of the rest of that part of the world, and then spread northward into Europe bringing "Western Civilization" by the sword, we count ourselves today, at least in part, as their cultural successors and, therefore, also the inheritors of some aspects of Greek culture which the Romans adopted. Euripedes holds high artistic merit in that heritage. That's why I watched this (subtitled) Greek produced, directed, and acted movie about a time right before the assembled armies of Greece set off for their war on Troy, under the leadership of brother kings Agamemnon and Menalaus, to avenge the "kidnapping" of Menelaus' wife, the (in)famous Helen of Troy, and, of course, to sack that city for its treasures and, thus, to pay the Greek army.

This is not a Hollywoodized version of the story. It looks much more like something that is like a historical re-enactment, intended to have as much authenticity as possible in the characters, the dialogue, the politics, setting, clothing and accoutrements of that time and place and Irene Pappas, as Agamemnon's wife and mother of the ill- or gloriously- fated (depending upon your point of view) Iphigenia, is a feast for not only for women's eyes and ears, but also for posing this whole tragic story on the edge of a knife that not only gave her her own place in the world, by way of another kidnapping, btw, but also put her daughter, on her sham or authentic (once again depending upon your point of view) wedding day to the pure and virginal Achilles, under that same knife for the will of the gods and in exchange for glory of the Greek army.

One theme I think the director transplanted subtly but well from Euripides is, of course, the Greek hero and, in this case, heroine and all that entails about the glory of certain kinds of death. I don't have everything I think about this sorted out yet, but I'm sure you will recognize some familiar themes: women as property; nationalism; women, relative to high male status, honored and yet absolutely and utterly vulnerable; the nobility of motherhood; and some minimalistic yet highly detailed family relationships, including Iphigenia to her little brother, Orestes, who loves her deeply and is witness to all but the sacrifice itself.

I'm struggling with the ending which is kind of a surprise in that Euripides apparently made it rather more positive than one would expect from the horror story that precedes it, though I suppose that is a cultural artifact and the whole piece is definitely more complicated than just the ending and yet the whole thing really does stick together too. It's odious, but coherent.

I hope you'll watch this movie, you'll love Irene Pappas, and maybe post any of your thoughts. It's bothering me, because, other than Achilles and Orestes who have more minor roles, the women are the only real heroes in the lot and yet their heroism is FOR and as accessories to what is going on amongst the men, or does Iphigenia's choice near the end change that? . . . or not? I know I'm not supposed to, but I think not.

6 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A piece of the cultural context for women's issues - Iphigenia: Women as accesories to nationalism (Original Post) patrice Feb 2013 OP
What bothers me about the Iliad ismnotwasm Feb 2013 #1
Yes!!! & in the Aeneid Dido, one of the queens Odysseus dallied with, immolates herself patrice Feb 2013 #2
I thought it was excellent Blue_Tires Feb 2013 #3
Good teacher! Your mind can climb all over that movie. Makes me want to go find a good patrice Feb 2013 #4
That looks good, never heard of it before..... Little Star Feb 2013 #5
It seems to have strong existentialist over-tones, so I was thinking it'd be good to patrice Feb 2013 #6

ismnotwasm

(41,989 posts)
1. What bothers me about the Iliad
Mon Feb 25, 2013, 10:09 AM
Feb 2013

Is the stories before and after about the fate of the losers, especially the women. It's interesting that the argument between Achilles and Agamemnon was over 'a slave girl'.

I haven't read this play, the movie sounds very interesting, thank you!

patrice

(47,992 posts)
2. Yes!!! & in the Aeneid Dido, one of the queens Odysseus dallied with, immolates herself
Mon Feb 25, 2013, 01:17 PM
Feb 2013

on a cliff above the ocean, when Odysseus (as Dido always knew he would) sets off again on his noble odyssey back to Ithaca.

It's been so long ago since I read those books, but Dido stuck with me; there's a pattern here: relationships to men, so loving, so deep, so "eternal" that the blood sacrifices themselves are validation of the women.

Notice that the women are QUEENS, validation of male ROYALTY, too; so those other lesser women, well . . . . we KNOW what happened to them, . . . kind of.

I just remembered it was the Aeneid, not the Odyssey, because I just remembered how one of my favorite undergrad lit instructors, Dr. Lawson, old, odd guy who really knew literature and had a deep love for Japanese culture, wrote a poem about Dido, for which I did a piece for my crit lit class, so I read quite a bit of the Aeneid.

That was back in the day when you could get an honest to god intellectual giant standing up front running some minor undergrad class. I'm not sure that's so anymore, but that's another story . . . .

(Heard some real sad stuff about one of our best universities here in the state of BrownKOCHistan, formerly known as Kansas, where the hatred of science is corroding the best university in the state.)

patrice

(47,992 posts)
4. Good teacher! Your mind can climb all over that movie. Makes me want to go find a good
Mon Feb 25, 2013, 09:31 PM
Feb 2013

translation of the original.

patrice

(47,992 posts)
6. It seems to have strong existentialist over-tones, so I was thinking it'd be good to
Tue Feb 26, 2013, 05:23 PM
Feb 2013

read the original too, to see if that stuff is in Euripedes.

I kind of bet that it is, because that kind of universality is what makes a classic a Classic.

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»History of Feminism»A piece of the cultural c...