The science populists who stoked a Reefer Madness-like hysteria about social media are onto their next target—and predictably predicting the imminent end of the world.
https://www.thedailybeast.com/the-social-media-panic-mongers-have-pivoted-to-ai
Artificial intelligence (AI) has in 2023 quickly eclipsed social media and smartphones as the technology du jour for secular doomsday preachers. Concerns about content-ranking algorithms and “dark patterns” suddenly felt quaint compared to sentient AI exterminating (or displacing) every human on the planet.
Mark Zuckerberg, once an unyielding digital titan, now feels like
MySpace Tom reigning over an uncool, increasingly irrelevant virtual realm.
This sudden narrative shift posed a dilemma for a cottage industry of self-styled “tech-ethicists” who once effortlessly garnered book deals, headlines, and interviews on the topic of social media-induced societal collapse. Now, they find themselves outcompeted in the attention economy by the likes of AI safety researchers like Elizer Yudkowsky, who called for
theoretical nuclear strikes on server farms in
Time magazine, and Connor Leahy, who went on CNN to
warn Christine Amanpour about the extinction of the human race. So, they hastily adjusted their messaging to compete.
Roger McNamee, author of the book,
Zucked: Waking Up to the Facebook Catastrophe, dismissed the positive potential of AI on CNN, only days after a
New York Times report on AI helping a paralyzed man walk again. Facebook whistleblower Francis Haugen
predicted 10 million deaths from social media while promoting her new book,
The Power of One: How I Found the Strength to Tell the Truth and Why I Blew the Whistle on Facebook. The influential public intellectual Yuval Noah Harari, author of
Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind, went from
calling free information “dangerous” to
suggesting tech executives should face jail for allowing AI generated profiles. All three signed their names to a March 2023
open letter—released by the Elon Musk-backed Future of Life Institute—which demanded a six-month hiatus on AI development.
Also among the letter’s signees was
Tristan Harris, the photogenic poster boy of tech-ethicism who famously eschewed his six-figure Silicon Valley salary—after pushing for design ethics at Google—to start the
Center for Humane Tech, where he led a crusade against smartphones and social media. Harris’ influence and profile has now risen to the point of being invited to a
recent Senate meeting on AI, along with Bill Gates and Elon Musk. A month after the letter’s publication, Harris and his team delivered a chilling presentation titled, “
The AI Dilemma,” a reference to the social media-panic documentary,
The Social Dilemma, of which they were also heavily involved. In the film, Harris claimed, “no one ever said this about the bicycle”—in regards to social media’s impact on society—which is an ahistorical statement, quickly (and ironically) fact-checked on social media.
https://twitter.com/PessimistsArc/status/1446478115732172801
snip