General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Donald Trump Jr. Gets Holy Hell Over Bible Fundraiser Video [View all]Hekate
(90,674 posts)
were so keen on keeping a wall of separation between Church and State. They were well-educated men, and the history they studied in college was far more recent to their age than to ours.
Let me give you the short version: for century after century after century the soil of Europe had been soaked with the blood of people whod been deemed heretics. The Church spoke with the voice of God and Kings ruled by the grace of God, and different opinions were not tolerated. The sword, the gibbet, the pyre, and very inventive means of torture were all ways of ferreting out heresy, forcing confessions of heresy, and punishing heresy,
When European settlers landed in the New World, they had many motives, but a key one in early days was to be left alone regarding how they saw God, who was a real entity to them. They were not necessarily tolerant of other beliefs themselves, but America afforded them something Europe and the British Isles had not: the ability to leave the vicinity and start their own church. Sometimes they didnt have to go far; the people who disagreed could just build another church on the other side of town.
America has been good to those kind of rebels and others. America also has been great for people who, based on the fact that they can read the Bible, believe they dont have to go to a theological seminary and test their ideas against old tradition or even rational thought. They talk straight to God or Gawd.
Look: go back to first principles as written by Franklin, Jefferson, and the rest and keep government out of religion and religion out of government. Beyond that, ensure that people living in accordance to some religious belief are free to do so as long as they follow the secular laws of the USA that apply to us all equally.
You go mucking about trying to define heresy in regard someones religious beliefs, you best do it from inside that religion. You leave the rest of us out of it. There is no we in that enterprise. I will stay far, far away first, because I believe its a fools errand, and second because I am way outside the majority as regards religion in the US, and it is the First Amendment that protects me.