Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DFW

(59,588 posts)
25. Some rather broad generalizations, I find
Sat Nov 30, 2024, 03:59 PM
Nov 2024

He ignores that the administrations if Clinton, Obama and Biden were periods of relative prosperity, compared to Bush I, Bush II, and Trump I. Not everyone rode the gravy train, obviously, but even those living paycheck to paycheck WERE getting that paycheck. Unemployment sank when the Democrats were running things. Those who were not getting a paycheck declined in number. The masses in France in 1789 and Russia in 1917 were having serious mass hunger issues. We are not. We the people set up food banks, soup kitchens, etc. Not some Republican “Christian” charity, but popular initiative.

It’s easy to say, look what happened to the Roman Empire, or look what happened to Germany in 1933, but it’s never that simple. One thing postwar Germany learned from the collapse of the Weimarer Republik was not to let tiny fringe parties have parliamentary representation if they got under 5% of the vote. The Weimarer Republik gave seats to every nutcase movement that could get a few thousand party goers to vote them in. It’s as if Jill Stein were given a Senate seat because 40,000 Americans nationwide voted for her. The Reichstag never got anything done, and the National Socialists (Nazis, for short) said, “we will!” Forty-two per cent of the German voters decided to give them the chance. Clinton, Obama and Biden got plenty done. It took Republican control of the media, and probably some serious Russian and Chinese internet involvement, to convince half the country that they didn’t really.

If you oversimplify, you get it wrong.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

This is full of irony. LakeVermilion Nov 2024 #1
Such is the power of the propaganda constantly being put out by rightwing corporate media. sop Nov 2024 #3
A sea of True Dough Nov 2024 #2
Immiseration--the act of making miserable. Timeflyer Nov 2024 #4
Looking at the camera, Frances Perkins. NT mahatmakanejeeves Nov 2024 #5
This is a major false conclusion Cosmocat Nov 2024 #6
Agree, except the last paragraph. Martin Eden Nov 2024 #12
Agreed! Cosmocat Dec 2024 #29
As 62% of the American people are living paycheck to paycheck how do they relate to a "good economy?" Uncle Joe Nov 2024 #23
You mean like the great economy under Trump? dpibel Nov 2024 #27
The point of my post was that it has been going on for decades. Uncle Joe Nov 2024 #28
Bingo Cosmocat Dec 2024 #30
Bingo Cosmocat Dec 2024 #31
As another poster correctly noted Cosmocat Dec 2024 #32
That was my point in both posts, this is decades in the making, and as Uncle Joe Dec 2024 #33
Delusion And Malevolence Are The Deep Historical Forces MayReasonRule Nov 2024 #7
Neo-liberalism was the death of the social good malaise Nov 2024 #8
People are really overthinking this... Blue_Tires Nov 2024 #9
Excellent read. underpants Nov 2024 #10
Time again to Bust the Trusts surfered Nov 2024 #11
Well, that about says it. It's a mess out there. Buckle up Joinfortmill Nov 2024 #13
Left unsaid Icanthinkformyself Nov 2024 #14
Fascist playbook usonian Nov 2024 #15
A complete pile of garbage TheDemsshouldhireme Nov 2024 #16
Your problem is that you can't think like an imbecile! Gotta channel the MAGA. Fish700 Nov 2024 #21
we didn't win nowforever Nov 2024 #17
He left out one important thing: yellow journalism RainCaster Nov 2024 #18
Please read, people. Joinfortmill Nov 2024 #19
It has always been sickening PATRICK Nov 2024 #20
It is an interesting read and I am somewhat convinced. My pet theory is a lot of people have it too good, got bored, Fish700 Nov 2024 #22
Essay is a bit over the top, but it rightly points out the ongoing realignment of the working class with the GOP andym Nov 2024 #24
Some rather broad generalizations, I find DFW Nov 2024 #25
Vulture capital union-busting began in the late 1960s bucolic_frolic Nov 2024 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Guardian: The deep hi...»Reply #25