Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Schumer made the smart move. [View all]lapucelle
(20,352 posts)137. Sorry, but I don't take Trump's "praise" of Democrats at face value.
He's trolling Schumer with fake praise the same way he has trolled AOC with fake praise in the past. Are all cases of Trump gratuitously praising Democrats "unforgivable" or only some?
As for
HOW THE FUCK DOES THIS LOOK TO ANY RATIONAL PERSON?
It probably looks like Schumer re-evaluated and changed course.

Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
259 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations

I assumed that Schumer weighed all the options and did what he thought was right. I don't think he did it on a whim.
Walleye
Mar 2025
#1
Definitely a hostage situation. Trump loves this so he can gloat afterwards. Apparently it's all he lives for.
Walleye
Mar 2025
#59
He's probably already planning his Fourth of July parade with tanks rolling down Pennsylvania AvenueI'm
Walleye
Mar 2025
#166
Maybe, that is hard to tell at this point. A lot is going to happen between now and then.
33taw
Mar 2025
#7
+1, The OP leaves out the biggest take is this vote was our only leverage politically
uponit7771
Mar 2025
#88
Quinnipac poll put shutdown squarely on MAGA/Trump ...those were the facts we had
uponit7771
Mar 2025
#108
That's speculation that doesn't match up historically, few times has Americans switch blame over time cause one ...
uponit7771
Mar 2025
#141
The poll question itself was speculative, and the Trump/Republican message that Democrats were to blame
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#174
Actually 32% of the respondents were ready to blame congressional Democrats.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#175
The right move was to not shut down the government, but thank you for your input.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#12
Those clean hands will help us win special elections and take back the House in 2026.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#67
Most Americans blamed Trump/MAGA for shutdown... This makes no sense in regards to political consequences
uponit7771
Mar 2025
#92
In the abstract, in one poll taken before any shutdown had occurred, the majority would have blamed Trump or Republicans
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#109
Enron and Putin's Puppet is going to slash government anyway might as well impose severe political cost on them ...
uponit7771
Mar 2025
#143
How many times did potus trump shut down the government as 45? Who is currently in charge?
krawhitham
Mar 2025
#246
But if they didin't vote "yes, then the GQP would say Bad Things 'Bout Dems. But now . . .
hatrack
Mar 2025
#84
I know. And by agreeing with hundreds of Democrats against 10, I'm told, we're just people
Scrivener7
Mar 2025
#107
So when does a meaningful stand happen? They continue virtually unabated....speed is the only variable.
dutch777
Mar 2025
#9
Thank you! I am where you are-- tragically and sadly. I am looking into the Indivisible Project....gotta DO something!
dutch777
Mar 2025
#177
When the price of Dry Powder moves beyond a certain $/ton figure, then - look out!!!
hatrack
Mar 2025
#90
Yeah, not quite sure what that price is indeed. Guess we are trying to corner the market...before we die on our knees.
dutch777
Mar 2025
#178
So then why do you think all the other Dems who voted "no" were not convinced? Or do you believe them
hlthe2b
Mar 2025
#10
I'm sure that all the Democratic senators who voted against the CR will be releasing statements, but
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#16
Your comment is best addressed to Senator Murphy who assumed that the Courts would remain open.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#39
The courts are open and going through the motions, but without enforcement, what good are they?
Magoo48
Mar 2025
#45
Well that's reassuring. At this point the "the courts are useless" narrative is truly defeatist.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#63
I have to reluctantly agree. His worshipers need to feel the pain of his policies.
louis-t
Mar 2025
#14
I agree, but "Schumer Caved" is a better headline than "Senate Democrats Shut Down Government".
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#19
How so? That claim requires the assumption that Democrats have accomplished nothing since 1985.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#52
Oh good grief, it doesn't mean that. It just means we've been going along to get along.
CrispyQ
Mar 2025
#65
This infighting wouldn't have occurred if those who wanted to abolish the filibuster the last few years had prevailed
MichMan
Mar 2025
#18
Democrats should NOT have voted to give Trump the power to spend or withold funds as he sees fit.
Martin Eden
Mar 2025
#123
The legality of his spending money he doesn't have the right to spend, doesn't change if the govt shuts down.
CrispyQ
Mar 2025
#40
Political consequences for MAGA would be devastating, 53% of Americans already blamed them...
uponit7771
Mar 2025
#105
THis: "The only power Senate Democrats had was to shut down the government, and that move would have put Trump's OMB in
Amaryllis
Mar 2025
#82
It wasnt OMB running teh show during the shutdown that made me change my mind; it was that OMB could run the show
Amaryllis
Mar 2025
#171
Shutting down the government would have been burning down the village to save it.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#73
What are you talking about? That's the second time today that someone invoked a Hitler comparison
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#77
I know I feel comforted that 9 Dems and 1 Ind chose to defy 213 House Dems and 38 Senate Dems
Nanjeanne
Mar 2025
#80
And, somehow, stating that makes you someone who "is just complaining about Democrats!!1!"
Scrivener7
Mar 2025
#89
Yep. Exactly. But that's what I'm told by people who always insist that our Democratic leaders can do no wrong
Scrivener7
Mar 2025
#98
On numerous occasions he has stood up for people on the (Wall) Street. /nt
thought crime
Mar 2025
#224
Thank you for acknowledging that "the Democrats folded like a cheap suit" is a Republican talking point. N/T
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#125
Closing the government would result in the government being dismantled at a quicker pace,
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#147
That was the only one poll, and the picture was not quite as rosy as some made it out to be.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#148
Pro-tip: Read carefully. Don't answer questions when none were asked. It will save the embarrassment
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#152
Apology accepted. Interesting hypothetical: Someone takes the liberty of answering for someone else,
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#156
Welcome to DU re your first post though you've been here a few months. . . . .nt
Bernardo de La Paz
Mar 2025
#161
You should inform the donors whom you know professionally that the stock market is closed on Saturdays.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#163
I've yet to hear an exit strategy from anyone who wanted to shut the government down.
lapucelle
Mar 2025
#176
Schumer publicly started a civil war in the Democratic Party. If that's "Smart" I'd rather be lobotomized. n/t
Hellbound Hellhound
Mar 2025
#170
So when they put in a national abortion ban in the next extortion CR Dems will just auto vote for it?
lark
Mar 2025
#181
Wholly Disagree -- Schumer's Top Donors Were Bleeding MARKET VALUE... All About The Benjamins...
MayReasonRule
Mar 2025
#184
Schumer says he agrees with Trump's decision to pull $400 million from Columbia.
MayReasonRule
Mar 2025
#185
Has he stood before a mic and declared the orange convict and musky domestic enemies
Hotler
Mar 2025
#196
Could not disagree more... fighting for We The People is what wins elections!!
InAbLuEsTaTe
Mar 2025
#226
Makes sense...but he would have exploited the situation had the Dem's shut it down..would have been ugly
NowsTheTime
Mar 2025
#238
Thanks! Yes we are. Having said what I did, I would like to see a stronger leader in the Senate.
NowsTheTime
Mar 2025
#245
A shutdown would have given musk/DOGE free reign to fire people and close offices
LetMyPeopleVote
Mar 2025
#257