General Discussion

Eko

(9,628 posts)

29. It is late. But I will still respond.

Mon Jul 28, 2025, 12:28 AM

Jul 28

For your first point (a safe place where I can go) I think the numbers show you are safer here in the US than in Israel. The whole hamas attack that killed over a thousand people plus the rockets they kept shooting that closed large parts of Israel kind of overshadows anything happening here in the US.

"Jerusalem is important to Jewish people", that is a religious thing. If Religion is a reason why the Jewish people should be there then as an atheist I am automatically against that in principle. I don't think religion gives anyone a right over others at all.

Many people have a history in another place and many of them have been persecuted throughout history.

"There are several Islamic countries" Do you think it is right for a country that has a state sponsored religion? I don't.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

38 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

'The Jews did something': US podcast under fire for antisemitic segment on Holocaust [View all] Beastly Boy Jul 27 OP

More about that podcast... AStern Jul 27 #1

The 2 co-hosts Celerity Jul 27 #12

Welp, FU Myron! electric_blue68 Jul 27 #14

The manosphere is full of utterly horrible people. EdmondDantes_ Jul 28 #28

Why would someone debate that? Eko Jul 27 #2

Question: if every mention of "Jew" in this article were to be replaced with "Zionist", would it stop being clear Beastly Boy Jul 27 #10

Zionism is a belief that some Jewish people have. Eko Jul 27 #11

Wow. Beastly Boy Jul 27 #16

Technically it is not. Eko Jul 27 #17

I dont believe in Zionism Eko Jul 27 #18

"Believe'? in Zionism? elleng Jul 27 #19

Yes, its a belief. Do I have a right to a homeland? Eko Jul 27 #20

Same as do I. elleng Jul 27 #22

Lets talk about this some more. Eko Jul 27 #21

Good questions. Thanks. elleng Jul 27 #23

If you were being persecuted because of your ancestry, you would want to be able to seek refuge there Mossfern Jul 28 #26

It is late. But I will still respond. Eko Jul 28 #29

I be believe that most Jewish people believe in Zionism Mossfern Jul 27 #24

I have not found any poll that shows that most Jewish people believe in Zionism. Eko Jul 28 #25

You did not grow up with the history Mossfern Jul 28 #30

And what makes you think Israel is safer for Jewish people than the US? Eko Jul 28 #31

I can honestly say for myself and for many Americans if the American Government starts going after Jewish people Eko Jul 28 #32

Thank you for that Mossfern Jul 28 #33

Anything can happen. Eko Jul 28 #35

Yes, that's true Mossfern Jul 28 #38

will the government be going after them like they did the Universities? Takket Jul 27 #3

Bingo mjvpi Jul 27 #4

Good question - Again, this is on a RW platform funded by the vice president- JD Vance and Peter Thiel tulipsandroses Jul 28 #27

This podcast sounds repellent and historically inaccurate.. they should be called out for antisemitism. mjvpi Jul 27 #5

This is Sickening and heartbreaking. Cha Jul 27 #6

Rumble is RW nutjob site. It is backed by JD Vance - It is a cesspool full of MAGATs, racists and bigots. tulipsandroses Jul 27 #7

I have no words mcar Jul 27 #8

The more things change, the more they stay the same. sarisataka Jul 27 #9

How does the fitness industry attract so many Nazis? WTF? Initech Jul 27 #13

steroids Mossfern Jul 28 #34

Gah! Hideious, hienious Lies! Eff them! electric_blue68 Jul 27 #15

"The non-jews 'did something'--- I think it was called 'the holocaust' " Jack Valentino Jul 28 #36

He's not the problem MaineBlueBear Jul 28 #37