Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

bigtree

(92,630 posts)
9. it's backed up by actual legislation. It's public advocacy from the elevation of his high office
Thu Sep 18, 2025, 06:45 PM
Sep 18

...representing the nearly half of the Senate that Democrats sent to D.C. without the power to do more than just talk. So it's really disingenuous to crack on Shumer or any Democrat in Congress for their inability to effect anything legislativly on their own initiative.

It's just specious criticism, and it's not actual advocacy for anything they're working to effect.

I refuse to take seriously folks' critique of Democratic legislators' efforts that comes with nothing but personal derision of actual Democratic action; nitpicking legislative resistance to republicans and Trump that so many insist isn't happening, then complaining that it's not enough.

I seriously don't know who all that's supposed to be directed to. Not me.

I will discuss and possibly debate actual legislation that many people bother to, or manage to, look up and post.

Your assertion that Democrats shouldn't make demands because they can't effect legislation right now with their own votes in the minority is absurd; essentially a misunderstanding of their minority role, and apparent misunderstanding of the entire political system of government.

I'll leave it here.

WATCH: Senator Murphy, Senator Schumer, Representative Crow, Senator Van Hollen, Senator Smith, Representative Casar, and Representative Houlahan are LIVE with their new bill to protect free speech in the wake of the Trump administration’s attacks on it:


Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I remember when these calls to resign made by members of either party actually meant something. sop Sep 18 #1
this one comes behind actual legislation bigtree Sep 18 #2
Totally agree Carr should go or muzzled. But why "demand" something that you know won't happen, it's kind of like drawin Silent Type Sep 18 #3
that goes against advocacy and activism, itself bigtree Sep 18 #4
Fine, keep demanding and report back when it's effective. Silent Type Sep 18 #5
wow bigtree Sep 18 #6
Schumer's demands are embarrassingly weak, honestly. I take no pleasure in saying that, but it's true. Silent Type Sep 18 #7
it's backed up by actual legislation. It's public advocacy from the elevation of his high office bigtree Sep 18 #9
THAT'S YOUR OPIION. THE DEMS ARE Cha Sep 18 #10
Yeah, let's continue the same old ineffective things. Silent Type Sep 18 #11
What would be effective with respect to Carr? onenote Friday #20
And here we go mcar Friday #14
Personally, I don't care what they do to rally those that voted for Democrats. What matters is attracting some Silent Type Friday #15
Exactly, mcar... TY for Pointing That Cha Friday #17
And the insults make no sense, Cha mcar Friday #18
Yes, that's what's So Frustrating. Cha Friday #22
We wouldn't be on this sinking ship mcar Friday #24
Precisely. That's the Irrefutable Bottom Line. Cha Friday #25
Then there's this: SpankMe Sep 18 #8
A lot more then him need to be arrested when the Democratic Party tinymontgomery Sep 18 #12
FCC Chair Carr should be removed from office--- Jack Valentino Sep 18 #13
How do you suggest we make that happen? onenote Friday #23
Will he get a Day of Remembrance when he's gone? leftstreet Friday #16
K&R spanone Friday #19
K&R UTUSN Friday #21
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Sen. Schumer demands FCC ...»Reply #9