Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

pinkstarburst

(1,810 posts)
8. It would be terrible for us politically to challenge
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 12:24 PM
Sep 20

The H1B program is horribly abused, and it's abused so that companies can fire American workers making good wages--like people in tech, and replace them with immigrant workers that they pay a slave wage to. Computer science grads are finding they are not able to get hired and H1B abuse is a huge part of that. The program was intended so that companies could hire workers when there were no Americans available to work that job. Instead Silicon Valley has become mostly H1B hires, while US computer science grads can't find jobs.

It's being horribly abused.

And if Democrats were to be crazy enough to jump on the bandwagon of trying to support H1B workers from India and their right to American jobs, over US workers who are being fired in order to give those H1B workers from India their jobs, it would be political suicide.

There is sympathy for what is happening to immigrants right now IMHO in large part because the image in many people's minds is that these are hard working people who are working out in the fields and working in meat packing plants and doing jobs US citizens really don't want to do. Watch how fast voters turn on democrats if we start making the argument that we should be for protecting H1B abuse when US citizens are having good, high-paying tech jobs taken from them, and when they can't get rehired, and when new grads can't get hired, and our argument is "but those Indian H1B visa holders should have a job, too."

It's like we want to lose elections...

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Not a single day can go by without some stupid Klarkashton Sep 20 #1
Per year AND offer discount as they see fit underpants Sep 20 #2
20+ years in biopharma, the program is being abused to avoid paying higher wages to Americans. WarGamer Sep 20 #5
$750-$1500 administrative fees. n/t Ms. Toad Sep 20 #6
I couldn't get the text or posts fully post here. ??? underpants Sep 20 #11
Will be challenged in courts dweller Sep 20 #3
Why would Dems challenge? WarGamer Sep 20 #4
I don't know if anyone will challenge dweller Sep 20 #10
Why would Dems challenge a popular policy like this? pcdb Sep 20 #18
It would be terrible for us politically to challenge pinkstarburst Sep 20 #8
I don't disagree with you; however, The Madcap Sep 20 #12
I think this move stems from bad motives milestogo Sep 20 #13
Everything they do stems from bad motives, obviously pinkstarburst Sep 20 #14
They made them related to entry and visa stamps renewal to bypass congesss uponit7771 Sep 20 #15
Certifiably insane policy. The Madcap Sep 20 #7
Trump has little understanding of money. He had over 400 million from his daddy, had bailouts when his Doodley Sep 20 #9
The administration has created a loophole that allows them to offer a $100,00 discount to any person the administration LetMyPeopleVote Sep 20 #16
Why would anyone even want to come here at this point? LS0999 Sep 20 #17
Pedoprez TACO 'd uponit7771 Sep 22 #19
clown show continues... democratsruletheday Sep 22 #20
They can decide whether to exempt a company JI7 Sep 22 #21
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump Increases Fee for H...»Reply #8