General Discussion

Wiz Imp

(7,593 posts)

8. Comparing Goebbels' "The Storm is Coming" and Miller's Charlie Kirk Memorial Speech

Fri Sep 26, 2025, 11:45 PM

Sep 26

It's effectively the same speech
https://www.parrott.ink/comparing-goebbels-and-miller/

snip
Conclusion: Structural Parallels and Historical Echoes
The structural similarities between these speeches are striking and deeply concerning. Both employ:

1. Apocalyptic crisis narratives that frame the current moment as decisive
2. Complete dehumanization of political opponents
3. Exclusive claims to civilizational legitimacy and historical inheritance
4. Martyrdom themes that transform violence into motivation
5. Messianic destiny rhetoric suggesting inevitable triumph
6. Military and warrior metaphors that frame politics as warfare

Miller's speech additionally incorporates several well-documented themes from contemporary white nationalist rhetoric, including "Great Replacement" civilizational claims, apocalyptic "final battle" framing, and accelerationist martyrdom themes.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

peggysue2

11 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

this is terrifying.....ex-white-supremacist, ex-christian-nationalist decodes stephen miller's speech at... [View all] Gato Moteado Sep 26 OP

Greatest Page for you, my dear Gato! CaliforniaPeggy Sep 26 #1

Been thinking of you, hope you are resting and feeling well, CaliforniaPeggy Maru Kitteh Sep 26 #7

Thank you, dear Maru Kitteh! I am feeling quite good with my usual energy! CaliforniaPeggy Saturday #10

You can feel her pain in her emotional response. I'm glad she was able to break away so thoroughly. chowder66 Sep 26 #2

yes.....it appears she was groomed as a child and raised in that community.... Gato Moteado Sep 26 #6

I'm going to steal a comment I saw in response to her video on Youtube Wiz Imp Sep 26 #9

This shows why it is so important to CivicGrief Sep 26 #3

on its face, the miller speech was creepy and nazi-like.... Gato Moteado Sep 26 #4

I wonder how that would have sounded in German. Crunchy Frog Sep 26 #5

Comparing Goebbels' "The Storm is Coming" and Miller's Charlie Kirk Memorial Speech Wiz Imp Sep 26 #8

Bookmarking to see later! Maru Kitteh Saturday #11