Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mntleo2

(2,602 posts)
109. Corruption also happens in these courts with foster care and adoption ...
Thu Aug 1, 2013, 12:54 PM
Aug 2013

...There is a heueueuge industry profiting off the same court system as this judge involving $Billions per state in contracted private corporations and state agencies under DSHS CPS. While a lot of is is "legal" a great deal of illegal activities are simply ignored and become "legal precedence" meaning that the court routinely ignores Constitutional rights and breaks the law and this is supposedly OK.

These agencies get their funding based on Title IV that uses Social Security money for the sole purpose of taking kids from their families. Their mandates in essence say, "The more kids you take, the money you will make. If you return these children home, you will LOSE all present and future funding..."

Each state receives approximately, depending on the state, $1.2 BILLION dollars of this Title IV money. They also go in and take an additional 1/3 of any money allocated for low income assistance in food stamps, medical, housing and cash assistance. I am saying that rather than assist a low income family, they get more money and even TAKE money literally "out of the mouths of babes" in order to take their kids and get 1000% more in funding for doing so. As a matter of fact within the training of my own (WA) state's DSHS, TANF (welfare) case managers are encouraged to report to CPS for anyone applying for assistance.

On the average an agency gets about $8000 per "legally kidnapped" child per month while it would cost less than $1200 of your tax dollars to actually support the family instead. On the ground what this means and transpires into is to target low income families' children using unconstitutional but now state-made unchallenged legal "reasons". They often use "reasons" as vague as mere "concern" without having to prove any proof of abuse at all. Additionally the laws now give case mangers bonuses for each child they successfully take ~ plus the raking in of funding by mega-nonprofits, and all their contracted agencies. All of these people are given complete total immunity for any consequences even after proving in court they have lied. Therefore it is profitable for everyone to take low income family's children. Your tax-paid personnel within DSHS and CPS will pay $thousands for everybody else BUT give any support for the birth family to care for these kids by simply accusing them of some kind of "child abuse". An average adoption brings in an additional $50,000-$100,000 per child.

I used to believe that the kids were truly abused when taken by CPS, but in fact even the Department of Social and Health Services admits that over 85% of these children are not abused. They also know that when they place these children in foster care and adoptions, these children have a 5-7X and greater chance of being physically and sexually abused than if they had simply given support to the families and left the kids in their home.

Rather than support these families, they take kids for many bad reasons. I have personally seen kids removed because the family cannot afford the water or electric bill (MI's private water companies actually pours cement down the pipes of a family with a delinquent bill). I have witnessed taking kids because their family cannot afford the heat bill, they have no telephone. They take kids because a parent could not take the child to a medical follow-up (often because the appointment can only be made at times that the parent is working and if the parent does not work they don't get paid, etc). I have witnessed kids taken because the kid wore the same clothes two times in a row to school, and because the the mother was a new mother and so "did not have the experience to parent" (who was adopted and reported abuse as a child but was never heard or was it addressed ~ until it became convenient to take her baby).

I have witnessed kids taken who have not been abused themselves but because the parent had been sexually or physically abused as children and so even though there is no evidence of their children being abused, because these parents had been abused, they might in the future sexually abuse their own kids. Many of these targeted parents were foster and adopted kids themselves who were abused in state-sanctioned homes. If the parent becomes ill and cannot work for a wage, rather than help the family , DSHS accuses the parent of "maltreatment and neglect" and takes their kids.

I have actually seen a low income housing building completely emptied of children taken one-by one, which the non-profit who owns this building "coincidently" also houses adoption and foster care agencies as well as DV lawyers who like to blame the victim rather than actually support them (cough, cough while saying Seattle YWCA). I have also learned this emptying of buildings of all the children regularly occurs in transitional and low income housing in PN, GA, MI, WA, CA. The only reason I do not mention any other states is those are the ones that I have had meetings with lawyers, clients, and other personnel from these states who have witnesses to these occurrences. NOBODY wants to address this. Rather than support a family, juvenile courts and all their minions get much more funding while mega-nonprofits and private corporations will prosper for simply destroying the family and taking their children.

The going philosophy is that if the children are taken from low income homes and placed in upper income homes, then everything is "fixed". Who cares what happens after that just as long as there is a new car in the driveway and the homeowner is at least middle class? Who cares about the terrible, deep, damage and detachment they impose on these children who will be affected for the rest of their lives or for the possible abuse they may face ~ just as long as everybody BUT their birth families profit? Did you know that a foster home has more legal rights if accused of child abuse than a grandparent who has never abused their grandchildren?

In my state (WA)for instance, just last month a low income couple who the State admitted had never abused their children, lost their 4 children and their parental rights terminated because supposedly they were "slow learners". The last child was taken directly from the hospital after birth (a great piece of "merchandise" since it was a white girl). DSHS got AT LEAST $32,000 per month for this as well as spending $thousands on court costs and contracted agencies. They created extremely high barriers insisting on impossible activities for this couple. For instance, as low wage workers they were instantly expected to become middle class and pay for a 4 bedroom home without any support to do so. DSHS CPS demanded the couple to pay a huge part of their meager incomes in child support while CPS was also receiving all this state and federal funding. CPS also made them pay for all the state contracted mental health "experts" who stood to profit by always going into court with the state's recommendations (and thus ensuring they would keep those contracts coming).

Meanwhile as this case was being prosecuted, they were digging up the bodies of several starved and beaten adopted children this same agency had placed in their "forever home". Using the glowing term "forever home" is an unfortunate description here ... And of course, after jumping through all those hoops and giving all the income they had, this low income couple lost. Not only will these decision makers ever face any consequences at all for permanently placing these dead children in their living hell, these agencies used these parents' kids for profit, knowing full well that nobody, including this couple would have enough resources to go up against the entire state who wanted their children for profit.

Grandparents have tried to save their grandchildren, losing everything, taking mortgages out on their homes (if they have one) and spending their entire nest eggs for naught trying to save their children from the System. They are hardly given a nod in court, considered not as important as the foster home with strangers where their grandchildren languish. They "get" to go through mourning of the legal death of their bloodline while watching their grandchildren sold to the highest bidders. The reason they have no rights and are not considered is that the juvenile courts and all their contracted minions would not profit off the Title IV mandates if they returned these children to their families.

These people well know that supporting families is not only far less expensive, it is more successful ~ even when the adult(s) have substance abuse issues. Adopted and foster children are more likely to drop out of school, become substance abusers, go to jail, become teen parents, and become homeless than if they had been left in the home with support. Yes kids should be taken from homes where they are being burned with cigarettes and beaten ~ but this is less than 15% of the children they take. Most of these families simply need support that costs far less ~ but unfortunately this would result in the loss of funding and profit for juvenile courts, these private corporations, nonprofits, and government agencies, should they do so.

The whole juvenile justice system is rife with tainted personnel and funding and it does not only deal with teens, it deals with ALL cases involving ANY child. Juvenile court is in actually a "pseudo court" that gets to make decisions about people's lives while being aware of where the profit lies. For decades with the use of low income children, they have been creating "legal precedence" for higher courts to use. They are routinely ignoring Constitutional rights impacting higher court decisions ~ especially when it is brought up to the SCOTUS' attention, which has ruled that all are immune, even though many courts have expressed deep concerns about the procedures these pseudo courts use. See the comments made by the 9th Circuit Court in Humphreys vs County of Los Angeles wherte this court openly stated they had little trust in the so-called 'internal" investigations" where the "investigations" are made by the people who are being "investigated". By being a "pseudo court" juvenile court can make accusations without ever having to prove a thing, and simply use vague and unprovable findings such as using someone's "feelings" or even though there is no evidence, they can prosecute people for what *might happen in the future" as fact.

These judges know much of the money that these "juvenile contractors" get is out of Title IV ~ as they themselves receive along with the many private and public agencies standing to get money for "saving the wittle baybees". Most juvenile judges are corrupt because they know what is going on. They have nothing to lose because they are often themselves getting "double pay" for being a juvenile court judge and a regular court judge, collecting twice the pay, accumulating twice the retirement, twice the paid sick leave, and twice the vacation pay for working one job. They well know that most teens who turn to the streets are foster children and adopted kids who have been taken from their family homes that their own courts and personnel refused to support. While being sexually exploited or abused, these kids who try to tell CPS about their suffering are ignored because who cares while letting these kids shiver in a doorway terrified to go to their assigned homes, left to wander the street, when their "forever homes" and all these agencies still get money whether or not the child actually lives in these homes anymore ? If they get in trouble, well it just means more for the courts, DSHS, keeps those judges in that double pay, and more funding for these "private contractors".

I am an activist for low income families. I see this happening every day. I know for a fact that juvenile courts are crooked and involves fraud not only with this judge, but it is happening nationally. Here are some links for those who want to know more:

*The first is the National Coalition for Child Protection Reform: http://www.nccpr.org. They have tons of white papers that have come out of the government, universities, and organizations such as the Casey Foundation about the studies cited on this post. http://www.nccpr.org.

*Here is a group of scrappy WI women who have gone out in their state and recorded what they have witnessed. These low income moms did better wonk work than any wonk in the nation would do about the profit making that comes out of "managing" the poor including CPS activities. Because of their activity, they have caused the prosecution of fraud that forced their legislators to request the return of funding, but they have barely scratched the surface and this activity is happening in every state as it not only involves local agencies, it involves agencies that are national and international: http://www.welfarewarriors.org/mwv_archive/sp09/sp09_milw.htm

*Here is another organization fighting the water rights issue in MI State. Kids are being taken because rather than assist these families with a $300.00 bill, they take the kids and get $8000 a month per child for taking them. You could speak to Maureen Taylor who is a vibrant speaker about this issue: http://mwro.org/

There are more organizations who are becoming aware of their own community's juvenile court corruption and the targeting of low income families. As one of these, I am a board member of POWER, http://www.mamapower.org who is also speaking to this corruption and demanding reform!

My 2 cents

Cat in Seattle

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What corruption! n/t Catherina Jul 2013 #1
That's just fucking evil. The Velveteen Ocelot Jul 2013 #2
He should have gotten life. nt Fantastic Anarchist Aug 2013 #71
Life..... JimboBillyBubbaBob Aug 2013 #88
Life without, imo. PorridgeGun Aug 2013 #89
He'll be 91 if he lives through the end of his sentence Orrex Aug 2013 #110
i don’t click on sites that I am don’t know but left is right Jul 2013 #3
4,000 convictions by this judge alone were thrown out, JimDandy Jul 2013 #35
If you don't click on sites you don't know how do you ever find out anything? hobbit709 Aug 2013 #72
Rot in prison you racist asshole. Rex Jul 2013 #4
A 28 year sentence for a 63 year-old like seems like JimDandy Jul 2013 #36
Slime,but I see NOTHING in the article that refers to black children. virgogal Jul 2013 #5
If you click on the link, Unknown Beatle Jul 2013 #11
That's the site. But the article? Igel Jul 2013 #25
I have to be honest... TeeYiYi Jul 2013 #57
I just copied and pasted the headline Unknown Beatle Aug 2013 #62
You are not obligated to cut-and-past false racists headlines. AnotherMcIntosh Aug 2013 #104
For profit prisons are evil. The whole friggin' ohheckyeah Jul 2013 #6
Nonsense. They are just smart businessmen. They buy the tools they need to make money. Ikonoklast Aug 2013 #75
Like I said - evil. n/t ohheckyeah Aug 2013 #119
How many lives did his greed ruin? lpbk2713 Jul 2013 #7
sounds like an Law and Order: SUV ep. warrior1 Jul 2013 #8
I actually know which one you're talking about. NuclearDem Jul 2013 #19
This is the judge from 2008 whopis01 Jul 2013 #37
Oh, right. NuclearDem Jul 2013 #38
what was the total years he stole from young peoples lives? PowerToThePeople Jul 2013 #9
In one case, the kid's life spiraled out of control. OnlinePoker Aug 2013 #112
holy fuck PowerToThePeople Aug 2013 #114
Let the civil lawsuit begin. Baitball Blogger Jul 2013 #10
I hope so rurallib Jul 2013 #27
Me either. PorridgeGun Aug 2013 #98
What happened to the youth centers that bribed pscot Jul 2013 #12
They pled guilty to several charges JimDandy Aug 2013 #60
Threw the guys they bribed directly under the first bus offered by the prosecutor. Ikonoklast Aug 2013 #78
Now how many other judges do the same thing but don't get caught? KeepItReal Jul 2013 #13
Yep. Cal Carpenter Aug 2013 #74
There are many more of them malaise Jul 2013 #14
Exactly! No more tokenism convictions. SEND THEM ALL to prison!! ~nt 99th_Monkey Jul 2013 #29
This is local news here. newcriminal Jul 2013 #15
I just copied and pasted the headline Unknown Beatle Jul 2013 #18
It wasn't just black children. Lugnut Jul 2013 #16
Very true. This county does not have a large African-American population JPZenger Aug 2013 #100
I honestly didn't think anything would ever happen to him Nevernose Jul 2013 #17
One of those pleasant suprises arely staircase Jul 2013 #47
What are the total years of all the kids' sentences? Daemonaquila Jul 2013 #20
Even if Treant Aug 2013 #93
He was judge in Luzerne County, which is only 3.4% Black or African American Divernan Jul 2013 #21
What happened to the private prison that was in cahoots with the judge? notadmblnd Jul 2013 #22
he is kind of pretty for a 63 year old olddots Jul 2013 #23
Are you trying to make a prison rape joke? Gravitycollapse Jul 2013 #24
I hope he rots there. City Lights Jul 2013 #26
I hope some of the people he meets DonCoquixote Jul 2013 #28
Everyone involved in this horror needs to go to prison and pay restitution. n/t MerryBlooms Jul 2013 #30
Why use such a misleading title? There is no mention of race in the text of the article... Taitertots Jul 2013 #31
Just click on this link Unknown Beatle Aug 2013 #63
But in doing so you repeat a lie which is extremely disrespectful of the victims. Bluenorthwest Aug 2013 #77
Well shame on you kcr Aug 2013 #97
Why include it? it is misleading Taitertots Aug 2013 #126
I'm assuming he will go to a federal prison. I hope he's incarcerated with rapists and murderers mountain grammy Jul 2013 #32
He's been incarcerated for two years. Lugnut Aug 2013 #111
Thanks. Forgot this was an old story.. mountain grammy Aug 2013 #117
I think this might be more common that we'd suspect. Whores in DC, whores on the bench. valerief Jul 2013 #33
This is the guy that Michael Moore exposed in "Capitalism: A Love Story".... Spitfire of ATJ Jul 2013 #34
he deserves life foe ruining lives for money. evil man Liberal_in_LA Jul 2013 #39
Have fun dying in prison. nt RedCappedBandit Jul 2013 #40
good to know his appeal failed. NT alp227 Jul 2013 #41
You certainly don't have much of this story correct, do you? matthews Jul 2013 #42
Hope this dirtbag dies in prison.....fuckin' asshole. n/t AverageJoe90 Jul 2013 #43
As long as it's slow and painful. jessie04 Jul 2013 #45
i hope he gets the living shit kicked out of him frylock Jul 2013 #44
That should be multiple life sentences. 28 years is a joke. TheKentuckian Jul 2013 #46
63 + 28 = 91 = Pretty much "life." WinkyDink Aug 2013 #92
Pretty much doesn't cut it. There should be a big fat 0% chance of release TheKentuckian Aug 2013 #125
True; he must not get out. This was my state, my local news coverage. This was so evil, WinkyDink Aug 2013 #127
I'll bet he'll be out within 5 years adieu Jul 2013 #48
18 1/2 years plunati43 Aug 2013 #121
I guess you didn't read the body of my post adieu Aug 2013 #122
Ha Ha! Major Nikon Jul 2013 #49
Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, YES!!!!! About goddamned time! nt MADem Jul 2013 #50
I remember reading about this fuck here couple of years ago DainBramaged Jul 2013 #51
What about the corporate @$$holes who bribed him? Jack Rabbit Jul 2013 #52
Excellent question. /nt Marr Aug 2013 #108
His name is Robert Mericle. Lugnut Aug 2013 #128
Thank you Jack Rabbit Aug 2013 #130
He pled guilty over 4 years ago! ConcernedCanuk Jul 2013 #53
Judge Kosik rejected Ciavarella's 2009 plea agreement, JimDandy Aug 2013 #61
Hallelujah! I hope he hates every minute of it for ruining those kids' lives! freshwest Jul 2013 #54
Mother confronts him after her son, victimized by Ciavarella, commits suicide KansDem Jul 2013 #55
He deserves to die in prison just for this case alone. Sheldon Cooper Jul 2013 #58
The headline of this article denies this young man was wronged at all. Bluenorthwest Aug 2013 #79
No it doesn't. Are you mentally compromised? Schema Thing Aug 2013 #94
It says the sentence was for sending black kids to jail. Not kids. It is exclusionary and Bluenorthwest Aug 2013 #95
Where are the convictions for the bribers and the private prison corporation? The Second Stone Jul 2013 #56
They have to build themselves luxury suites in their own prisons before they can serve time. tclambert Aug 2013 #69
Perp WALK!!... Perp WALK! bvar22 Jul 2013 #59
And the private prison execs burrowowl Aug 2013 #64
Another race baiting thread Boudica the Lyoness Aug 2013 #65
Hit Alert Then HangOnKids Aug 2013 #66
This judge's victims were far from all black. Lots of white kids, perhaps mostly white kids. Bluenorthwest Aug 2013 #82
x2 AnotherMcIntosh Aug 2013 #102
it appears PA Child Care is still in business Douglas Carpenter Aug 2013 #67
I'm shocked that we still have threads of justice remaining intact......nt Enthusiast Aug 2013 #68
He should have gotten life in prison. Fantastic Anarchist Aug 2013 #70
This headline is an insult to all of his victims of all races. Thousands of victims. White, black Bluenorthwest Aug 2013 #73
Exactly. AnotherMcIntosh Aug 2013 #103
Oh I would ADORE hearing the Oral Arguments before the SCOTUS on this one... Volaris Aug 2013 #76
Are you kidding? At least half of them would be furiously masturbating under their robes. Ikonoklast Aug 2013 #81
privatization = corruption spanone Aug 2013 #80
Good it's about time. This guy is lower than an earthworm's belly. (n/t) MadrasT Aug 2013 #83
rot in hell n/t warrprayer Aug 2013 #84
This is not the first judge who has been caught making money from sending people to jail. sabrina 1 Aug 2013 #85
Privatize, Privatize, Privitize. This is what you get. Fla Dem Aug 2013 #86
His name is now prisoner 15008-067 in Federal Prison in Pekin Illinois SummerSnow Aug 2013 #87
Long may he rot Tom Ripley Aug 2013 #90
the heaven05 Aug 2013 #91
Sooo happy to hear his appeal was denied!! Inside prison-->they have their own justice system!! hue Aug 2013 #96
A crooked Judge? retired rooster Aug 2013 #99
What an evil man. He deserves to be locked up forever. MotherPetrie Aug 2013 #101
An important story, kiva Aug 2013 #105
Disgusting rl6214 Aug 2013 #106
Example #493003 of why for-profit prisons are a bad idea, and private industry Marr Aug 2013 #107
Corruption also happens in these courts with foster care and adoption ... mntleo2 Aug 2013 #109
DSHS/DCFS/CSO/DLR corruption tillwill2004 Feb 2015 #131
OH yeah I know so deeply of your pain! mntleo2 Feb 2015 #132
To be clear: he put all sorts of kids away including a lot of white kids. marble falls Aug 2013 #113
Sweet Mr Dixon Aug 2013 #115
SMH Mr Dixon Aug 2013 #116
Its not going to be one of those foo-foo prisons is it? benld74 Aug 2013 #118
Whatever he gets, it's not enough. Bake Aug 2013 #120
I just wish there was a hell so that fucking prick would burn in it. Zoeisright Aug 2013 #123
He should be paying all $2.6 mil in restitution Ilsa Aug 2013 #124
Since I worked in … 1StrongBlackMan Aug 2013 #129
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Judge to serve 28 years a...»Reply #109