Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Former Top NSA Official: “We Are Now In A Police State” [View all]damnedifIknow
(3,183 posts)35. Same thing happened to me
I put a couple garbage bags in a can and I always set my garbage out the night before pickup and I went to throw something else away and my can was empty. I've also had a cop come to my door asking if I called the police and then saying he had the wrong address but was in no rush to leave as he asked what type of dog I had. Just weird small talk for about 5 minutes.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
167 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Looks to me that he has an axe to grind. And he has been gone from NSA for 12 years.
Tx4obama
Dec 2013
#3
He is a person of prinicple and is widely regarded as such. He knows what he is talking about
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#22
Yes, let's grind that ax and hone it perfectly. How many people are illegally imprisoned?
Coyotl
Dec 2013
#26
I am sure Congress will be working diligently to find that out, how many have been illegally
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#91
Yes. He has an ax to grind against the police state that GWB created. Apparently, you support
Luminous Animal
Dec 2013
#30
Funny how those who value civil liberties more than their own jobs have axes to grind
EOTE
Dec 2013
#86
Some attorneys focus on a particular area of the law not to protect it but to defeat it.
JimDandy
Dec 2013
#10
He was NEVER what could be called a "Professor of Constitutional Law, as if it was his speciality.
savannah43
Dec 2013
#15
He's not thinking of a police state, he's thinking of a slave state like Ancient Rome.
sibelian
Dec 2013
#36
I think it's call a "straw man" argument when you misrepresent an argument then argue against it.
rhett o rick
Dec 2013
#111
The posts shows that there is a market for personal data. The NSA has the capability to get
rhett o rick
Dec 2013
#149
With respect, you dont know what data Snowden got his hands on any more than I. You dont know what
rhett o rick
Dec 2013
#160
When you have to start an argument with "if this were a totalitarian state," you're in denial. n/t
winter is coming
Dec 2013
#66
Thanks. I was a little surprised (and grateful) than no one else had already claimed it. n/t
winter is coming
Dec 2013
#132
That would not be surprising at all. It was one of the first such forums to ask for so much personal
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#47
Your professor had better hope they don't decide to take down the stage setting
tavalon
Dec 2013
#98
Technically he is correct. We are not yet in a totalitarian state per the definition. We may be
rhett o rick
Dec 2013
#114
Like he thinks we haven't known that!! Why is it that no one can quite grasp a reality until some
ancianita
Dec 2013
#9
I did not know WHAT they were using this data for. I did not know they were passing it along to
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#49
Thank you, yes I remember that, that they were using the info to funnel to the DEA, but I did not
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#157
Great! Details! That are impossible to investigate with the PPPP in place, even for judges.
ancianita
Dec 2013
#153
Are you familiar with Binney at all? Binney is an NSA Whistle Blower who did NOT wait 'all this
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#156
Thank you. I'm not familiar with him. I'm now enlightened that he's been a crucial whistleblower.
ancianita
Dec 2013
#158
No problem, and I agree with you that people get tired of seeing the crimes exposed only to see
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#161
OK, mine is a stupid little anecdote, but I'm sure there are many more where like it so here goes...
Snarkoleptic
Dec 2013
#18
They're spying on us (and, everybody else) to protect us from tyranny where everybody is spied on.
Tierra_y_Libertad
Dec 2013
#23
All of the information gained by the NSA through spying is then shared with federal, state and local
Coyotl
Dec 2013
#24
Now let's ask our totalitarian police state to provide Nationalized Health care.
JoePhilly
Dec 2013
#42
So long as they don't exercise their first Amendment rights to protest, or become active in trying
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#51
Railing against an imaginary police state is easier than dealing with the real problems we face.
randome
Dec 2013
#74
Not every single activist has to be brutalized for the police to make their point.
NuclearDem
Dec 2013
#73
I think one of the recommendations for the NSA is to have a 'defendant advocate'.
randome
Dec 2013
#75
Well, they got 'caught' using a legal warrant. I guess we won't agree on how important that is.
randome
Dec 2013
#82
It's only hyperbole to those who believe they are safe from being targeted. But to the thousands
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#90
Thousands of OWS protesters were falsely arrested and jailed. Are you calling facts 'hyperbole' now?
sabrina 1
Dec 2013
#94
Here in Portland the FBI raided a house and arrested squatters involved in anti-corporate protests.
Maedhros
Dec 2013
#118
There doesn't seem to be a lot of remorse from Binney, considering he was one of the architects...
Blue_Tires
Dec 2013
#96
Looks like the 0.0001% couldn't care less about neither 'our' liberty or security.
Amonester
Dec 2013
#126
I'm going to do myself a favor and bypass the nauseating pro-tolalitarian responses K&R
whatchamacallit
Dec 2013
#133