General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Anyone else find equating pets and animals with humans to be rather strange? [View all]Vattel
(9,289 posts)Humans and dogs are animals who can, if they are lucky, get benefits from life. Other things being equal, a dog's suffering is just as bad as human's suffering. Suffering is suffering. As for survival, many factors are relevant to a comparison. Assuming the child has a good shot at a long, decent human life, I would think it likely that he or she would have more to lose by dying than the dog (since a dog's life span is relatively short) and so that would count in favor of saving the child. But other things being equal, I would save a young healthy dog with a bright future before I would save a brain dead human or a human that is terminally ill and will die soon anyways or even a very old human who has already had a long, full life.
Anyone who thinks that just because they are human their wellbeing is more important than a dog's is a human supremacist and that is not any better than being a white supremacist in my book.
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):