Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

4lbs

(7,395 posts)
36. Yeah, that's a good logical stance. Mine is rooted in science and reality.
Sat Apr 6, 2024, 03:43 PM
Apr 2024

Although I am a dude, my belief is that the "fetus" is not living until there is a heartbeat AND brain activity. That usually happens at what, after the first trimester?

Until then, it is a collection of cells, like cancer. Fetuses like cancer? Yup, to me they are at the beginning. They function almost exactly like cancerous tumors. They grow (multiply, divide, multiply, etc.), develop blood vessels, and consume nutrients from the host (the mother).

Since some cancers get to the point where they even grow hair and teeth, wouldn't having them removed surgically, through radiation, or chemical chemotherapy, be an abstract version of an abortion? Their fallacious logic affirms that is the case that can be made.

It isn't until we get a heartbeat AND brain activity that they then become something else.

I state both, because how many times have we experienced doctors say a patient is "brain dead"? But... there's a heartbeat and breathing. Yeah, but there's no active brain activity. The machines are doing the vital functions for him/her.

So, a heartbeat isn't enough. It must be matched with brain activity for me.

These "six week" abortion bans are a lame attempt at controlling women. Many women doin't even notice they might be pregnant and get tested until say, around 6 weeks. So, by the time most women find out they are pregnant, they cannot get an abortion, because of these lame-assed bans.

Using my logic above, these abortion bans can in a way, prevent a person from getting cancer treatment. Many people don't get diagnosed with cancer until after a few months to a year.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

This strikes me as funny, but I may have a warped sense of humor. CaliforniaPeggy Apr 2024 #1
Not funny, but "Be careful what you wish for" is correct. elleng Apr 2024 #5
My first thought! Hikerchick57 Apr 2024 #33
At least 2 of us have a warped sense of humor. lark Apr 2024 #11
I just want to chime into this sub-thread by three of my favorite posters. erronis Apr 2024 #12
Well, I didn't expect this from Indiana TexasBushwhacker Apr 2024 #2
So, you're saying..... (Cliff Notes here)........ MyOwnPeace Apr 2024 #3
Too funny Hikerchick57 Apr 2024 #34
Isn't religious liberty about believing what you want while not interfering with others? bucolic_frolic Apr 2024 #4
This is a silly take NanaCat Apr 2024 #17
Silly? Better than jaded. /nt bucolic_frolic Apr 2024 #19
Society of Friends comes to mind. malthaussen Apr 2024 #24
The law can always turn around and bite you on the butt. Jacson6 Apr 2024 #6
Whow. just plain WHOW!! riversedge Apr 2024 #7
Hmm... maybe we can have women join a new "religion", one that allows abortion 4lbs Apr 2024 #8
Great idea. And nothing says that you can't belong to multiple religions. erronis Apr 2024 #13
Jewish religion Delphinus Apr 2024 #15
Yes, they did. Grins Apr 2024 #26
These religions already exist, the Old Religion among them. 🌙 In addition Judaism, as my late MIL asserted strongly... Hekate Apr 2024 #29
Yeah, that's a good logical stance. Mine is rooted in science and reality. 4lbs Apr 2024 #36
Excellent! Hikerchick57 Apr 2024 #9
"the Dobbs Court" NT mahatmakanejeeves Apr 2024 #10
I'm sure it's coming as a deep shock to fundagelical Christians Warpy Apr 2024 #14
It's difficult to reason with people who are convinced that the US was founded as a Christian nation... Hekate Apr 2024 #32
That's why I'm so glad to see the "nones" become the majority Warpy Apr 2024 #35
I hope this holds for the sake of women in need of healthcare SouthernDem4ever Apr 2024 #16
Wish I could say Thomas and Alito were spinning in their graves over this decision rpannier Apr 2024 #18
anti choice folks E. Normus Apr 2024 #20
Makes total sense azureblue Apr 2024 #21
To me, these abortion bans are a violation of women's civil, and religious rights. patphil Apr 2024 #22
That is hysterical. Mikey is probably crying on 'Mother's' shoulder. appleannie1 Apr 2024 #23
This is funny, and raises a question: malthaussen Apr 2024 #25
So, when total abortion bans affect MEN in a negative way ... Diamond_Dog Apr 2024 #27
This is wonderful news!!! h2ebits Apr 2024 #28
Mother will not be pleased. louis-t Apr 2024 #30
Using their own logic against them tornado34jh Apr 2024 #31
Delicious!! riversedge Apr 2024 #37
Just so you all know... I have not stopped laughing about this. (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Apr 2024 #38
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Indiana appeals court use...»Reply #36