Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Bluetus

(1,998 posts)
34. I know Sen. Gallego was driving while recording, so he had to split his attention, but we're not talking about a "right"
Mon Nov 24, 2025, 06:35 PM
Monday

Let us be clear. Every citizen has a right to speak the truth under the First Amendment. Active duty soldiers may have that right restricted by the UCMJ. And this may apply to Kelly as retired receiving pension benefits, which is why they are only going against Kelly and not the other 5 who discharged before earning a pension. Nonetheless, Kelly did nothing in violation of UCMJ.

The issue here has nothing to do with rights, other than free speech. The issue is RESPONSIBILITIES. Everybody on active duty IS subject to UCMJ, and Article 92 of the UCMJ requires service members to obey lawful orders and disobey unlawful ones. It is a requirement, a responsibility, not a right.

This article summarizes the practicalities ofArticle 92.
https://mattbarrylaw.com/2024/11/10/unlawful-orders-in-the-military/

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I think this is going to backfire on Trump big time! Chasstev365 Monday #1
The word is...NEVER FUCK WITH A MARINE! SEMPER FIDELIS is for LIFE! ProudMNDemocrat Monday #2
Carry on Cherokee100 Monday #21
The fascists said being anti-fascist was terrorism, now the criminals say being against war crimes is treason. sop Monday #3
TY, Sen.Gallego. FU, Hegseth! You yourself are "sowing confusuion"; Ignoring the UCMJ's Article 92 .. electric_blue68 Monday #4
Article 92 doesn't explicitly state that there is no obligation to obey an unlawful order. It does so my implication. TomSlick Monday #42
Oh, sorry I was repeating something i saw quickly in reference Article 92 electric_blue68 Yesterday #49
No worries. That's why DU lets a retired judge advocate hang around. TomSlick 11 hrs ago #59
TY, and I'm glad they do (let u hang around 😉 ). Oh, yeah...I completely agree!... electric_blue68 10 hrs ago #60
Trembling for fear of a reality tv star. travelingthrulife 22 hrs ago #56
Good! I want Angry Dems! tonekat Monday #5
Which Democrats are complacent and deemed worthless? sheshe2 Monday #15
Is this necessary? mcar Monday #31
Nailed it! sheshe2 Yesterday #50
Thank you, Senator Gallego! Paladin Monday #6
Hegseth is like a GI Joe toy BonnieJW Monday #29
There's some relatively sophisticated vocabulary in that statement, ao I'm betting... 3catwoman3 Monday #7
He's probably familiar with the word from his days at fox PSPS Monday #9
As I never watch Fox News, I did not know that. 3catwoman3 Monday #10
LOL. I don't either but that's my speculation as to where he would see the word. PSPS Monday #46
Hegseth is never sober long enough to write big words. Irish_Dem Monday #11
Trump will threaten, harass, stalk, destroy anyone who crosses him. Irish_Dem Monday #8
He should of added timms139 Monday #12
The worst a court matial will send to Kelly The Grand Illuminist Monday #13
Oh god, let them try, MarineCombatEngineer Monday #16
Glad I'm just a retired Reserve weenie. COL Mustard Monday #41
Could this be any more assinine? Disaffected Monday #14
It doesn't. sheshe2 Yesterday #51
It equates if the commanders issue illegal orders. Mister Ed Yesterday #52
Thank you to Ruben Gallego for the courage to fight back. democrank Monday #17
When I first saw the words, "Seditious Six", joshdawg Monday #18
Haven't seen you in awhile! BumRushDaShow Monday #20
I don't share just a whole lot, joshdawg Yesterday #53
Hegsith is defensive because he knows that he's already committing grotesque human rights violations in murdering Uncle Joe Monday #19
Very well said. Botany Monday #22
Or Buttigieg... HariSeldon Monday #24
Pete's got chunks of guys like Kegsbreath in his stool Blue Owl Monday #30
This should be repeated frequently by every damm Democrat! ananda Monday #23
when Trump orders the illegal invasion of Venezuela pfitz59 Monday #25
i am going silently krakatoa right now over this and i aint a vet AllaN01Bear Monday #26
WooHoo! I love my Senators! StarryNite Monday #27
Kegsbreath needs to drop and give us 20 Blue Owl Monday #28
And from his wife, Gabby Giffords, a former House member who survived an assassination attempt... red dog 1 Monday #32
I'll see your Kelly and raise you a BidenRocks Monday #33
I know Sen. Gallego was driving while recording, so he had to split his attention, but we're not talking about a "right" Bluetus Monday #34
Read the oath you swore, assh#@le. I grow weary of these nazis. Evolve Dammit Monday #35
We have had some history with the culpability in "following orders" Thunderbeast Monday #36
Gallego Responds gfarber Monday #37
Go Gallego! Ckeyes Monday #38
Use elbows and feet. Leave deep bruises wolfie001 Monday #39
Pete - I'm pretty sure our troops are intelligent enough Mblaze Monday #40
What if the American people stood on street corners with sign calling for the military not to obey illegal orders. Hotler Monday #43
Warriors? lonely bird Monday #44
Hegseth will be bombing Americans soon BlueWaveNeverEnd Monday #45
Hegseth just admitted the orders are illegal Oliver Bolliver Butt Monday #47
I like the cut of his jib. LudwigPastorius Yesterday #48
EVERY effing Dem should post a similar video... returnee 23 hrs ago #54
It's truly astonishing that this clown is Secretary of Defense JoseBalow 22 hrs ago #55
Love this guy. Keep saying the F word out loud...fascism I mean. travelingthrulife 22 hrs ago #57
Drunk rages from an incompetent warrior are sure to be ignored. Clouds Passing 21 hrs ago #58
A word from the White House usonian 9 hrs ago #61
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»'F*ck You Guys!' Sen. Gal...»Reply #34