Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

brewens

(15,359 posts)
9. Das Boot hands down. I'd like to see a real good effort at US Navy submarine movie
Fri Jun 9, 2017, 06:11 PM
Jun 2017

made like Das Boot. There would be no shortage of sub careers and harrowing missions to portray. But you just know they wouldn't be able to help ruining it by going over the top.

Like the dogfights in Red Tails. I couldn't even finish watching it. If you really know WWII air combat, one scene in there is ridiculous. This German ace can make this wicked maneuver that basically flips his 109 around. Supposedly, one of the Red Tail Mustang pilots figures out how to do it to defeat him, if I remember right. Actually, I don't think I even saw that. I could just tell that was going to be what would happen later.

Mustang's weren't that kind of fighter plane. 109's were smaller and more limber. A Mustang pilot wouldn't get in a tight turning dogfight with one of those guys. Same with how our guys fought the Japanese Zero in the Pacific. You used "zoom and boom" tactics. They had speed, durability and power over the Zero, with almost all of our fighter models. You made sure you had an altitude advantage and used that to dive on them, blow into them and fire, and hope for hits and climb or dive away.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Das Boot by a landslide... dhill926 Jun 2017 #1
Hunt for Red October has some great music too!! yuiyoshida Jun 2017 #4
indeed it does... dhill926 Jun 2017 #19
"The Enemy Below" and its Star Trek reboot, "Balance of Terror" longship Jun 2017 #2
Yellow Submarine :) Chasstev365 Jun 2017 #3
That's what I was gonna say! ailsagirl Jun 2017 #5
Hey! My choice too! robertpaulsen Jun 2017 #6
Needs to be added as an option! SeattleVet Jun 2017 #17
It's up there now as option # 7 red dog 1 Jun 2017 #20
Thanks! SeattleVet Jun 2017 #21
Murder on the Atlantic Warpy Jun 2017 #7
It sounds like a good one. red dog 1 Jun 2017 #12
It's from the UK and the date is 2007 in various places it's on YouTube Warpy Jun 2017 #13
You're right....IMBD lists it as a TV movie from 1998, which is where I got that from red dog 1 Jun 2017 #16
Thanks for this post. cwydro Jun 2017 #49
Run Silent, Run Deep Motley13 Jun 2017 #8
Das Boot hands down. I'd like to see a real good effort at US Navy submarine movie brewens Jun 2017 #9
I'm currently reading a book by Stephen E. Ambrose called "Wild Blue".. red dog 1 Jun 2017 #18
Nice! The Tuskegee Airmen did a wonderful job. Just some of the combat scenes were not very brewens Jun 2017 #23
The miniseries "War And Remembrance" had a number of extended sequences Aristus Jun 2017 #33
The Russians Are Coming, The Russians Are Coming! Sanity Claws Jun 2017 #10
It received four Academy Award nominations, including for Best Picture red dog 1 Jun 2017 #15
One of my favorite movies, but doesn't count as a submarine film. jg10003 Jun 2017 #32
BLACK SEA!!! n/m bagelsforbreakfast Jun 2017 #11
It is impossible to make a bad submarine movie... First Speaker Jun 2017 #14
Hello Down There d_r Jun 2017 #22
For a flat out good laugh avebury Jun 2017 #24
also U-571 discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2017 #25
U-571 was one of the poll options, but I took it down to make room for Yellow Submarine red dog 1 Jun 2017 #46
I like Crimson Tide also... discntnt_irny_srcsm Jun 2017 #48
Down Periscope Afromania Jun 2017 #26
I like it too sakabatou Jun 2017 #35
ah! Afromania Jun 2017 #43
So claustrophobic the only one I remember sitting through was, Laffy Kat Jun 2017 #27
The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou C_U_L8R Jun 2017 #28
Tough one. Xolodno Jun 2017 #29
20,000 Leagues Under The Sea jberryhill Jun 2017 #30
Destination Tokyo - "The granddaddy of submarine films" jg10003 Jun 2017 #31
Das Boot. Aristus Jun 2017 #34
Assault on a Queen A HERETIC I AM Jun 2017 #36
Operation Petticoat stars Cary Grant. malthaussen Jun 2017 #37
Das Boot. In German. hunter Jun 2017 #38
Das Boot in German with English subtitles Kaleva Jun 2017 #39
Fantastic Voyage. miyazaki Jun 2017 #40
My brother has a Hunt for Red October story. mnhtnbb Jun 2017 #41
If I ran into James Earl Jones gratuitous Jun 2017 #42
Great story! red dog 1 Jun 2017 #47
The Russians are Coming!!! Sancho Jun 2017 #44
I loved that movie. Thanks. kairos12 Jun 2017 #45
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What's your favorite subm...»Reply #9