Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Economy
In reply to the discussion: Weekend Economists Silent Night Christmas Eve 2014 [View all]Demeter
(85,373 posts)9. Why Scrooge is an anti-capitalist hero, bravely resisting the commercialisation of Christmas
http://www.newstatesman.com/culture/2014/12/why-scrooge-anti-capitalist-hero-bravely-resisting-commercialisation-christmas
Each December, our media adorns itself with festive clichés as rapidly as a young boy throws tinsel on a yuletide tree. One word that reappears with grinding regularity is Scrooge, a term used to silence anyone who objects to the tiniest aspect of our annual consumerist orgy.
Its not difficult, for example, to find articles that say youd have to be a real Scrooge not to like this years John Lewis advert. Since I didnt like the advert, this claim got me thinking. Why arent I overjoyed at the sight of a young boy purchasing a mail-order bride for his sex-starved, imaginary penguin? Maybe I am a Scrooge. But then Scrooge, the miser from Charles Dickens A Christmas Carol (1843), isnt the villain that we typically assume. He represents, in fact, a figure of resistance to the capitalist vision of Christmas.
To begin with, Scrooge sees through the seasons shallow festivities viewing them as an ideological sham, or humbug. Discussing Bob Cratchit, he says my clerk, with fifteen shillings a week, and a wife and family, talking about a merry Christmas. Ill retire to Bedlam. The madness implied through his reference to Bedlam is that of Cratchit blithely accepting poverty as his natural state. Scrooge knows that singing carols and making merry wont provide Tiny Tim with much-needed food. As he says to his impoverished nephew, What is Christmas to you but a time for paying bills without money?
When do-gooders knock on his door asking for donations, he rejects their piecemeal charity and asks whether the Union workhouses would not be a better alternative. Here Scrooge shows himself to be an early advocate of state intervention. The workhouse has a deservedly awful reputation, but it was still a baby step along the road to a proper welfare state. Crucially, he understands that individualist philanthropy is not the answer to structural poverty, whatever our tax-dodging, millionaire musicians might say to the contrary.
Scrooge is a heroic character, at least as far as preserving life on this planet goes. He is famously frugal: limiting the amount of coal he burns at home, and sitting by the light of a fire rather than spending money on gas. Though motivated by saving money (Darkness is cheap), his actions result in a low-emission lifestyle that could preserve the earth for future generations. Scrooge would love the savings to be made by installing solar panels.
Unlike the CEOs, bankers and politicians of today, he does not impose austerity from a luxury yacht. He is not willing to spend frivolous money on himself any more than he would on others. This attitude, which seems mean-spirited, can also be highly radical. If everyone consumed like Scrooge today then capitalism would collapse within a few weeks, which makes him a strange choice of hero for those on the neo-liberal right...
AND THE BEATING GOES ON...
Each December, our media adorns itself with festive clichés as rapidly as a young boy throws tinsel on a yuletide tree. One word that reappears with grinding regularity is Scrooge, a term used to silence anyone who objects to the tiniest aspect of our annual consumerist orgy.
Its not difficult, for example, to find articles that say youd have to be a real Scrooge not to like this years John Lewis advert. Since I didnt like the advert, this claim got me thinking. Why arent I overjoyed at the sight of a young boy purchasing a mail-order bride for his sex-starved, imaginary penguin? Maybe I am a Scrooge. But then Scrooge, the miser from Charles Dickens A Christmas Carol (1843), isnt the villain that we typically assume. He represents, in fact, a figure of resistance to the capitalist vision of Christmas.
To begin with, Scrooge sees through the seasons shallow festivities viewing them as an ideological sham, or humbug. Discussing Bob Cratchit, he says my clerk, with fifteen shillings a week, and a wife and family, talking about a merry Christmas. Ill retire to Bedlam. The madness implied through his reference to Bedlam is that of Cratchit blithely accepting poverty as his natural state. Scrooge knows that singing carols and making merry wont provide Tiny Tim with much-needed food. As he says to his impoverished nephew, What is Christmas to you but a time for paying bills without money?
When do-gooders knock on his door asking for donations, he rejects their piecemeal charity and asks whether the Union workhouses would not be a better alternative. Here Scrooge shows himself to be an early advocate of state intervention. The workhouse has a deservedly awful reputation, but it was still a baby step along the road to a proper welfare state. Crucially, he understands that individualist philanthropy is not the answer to structural poverty, whatever our tax-dodging, millionaire musicians might say to the contrary.
Scrooge is a heroic character, at least as far as preserving life on this planet goes. He is famously frugal: limiting the amount of coal he burns at home, and sitting by the light of a fire rather than spending money on gas. Though motivated by saving money (Darkness is cheap), his actions result in a low-emission lifestyle that could preserve the earth for future generations. Scrooge would love the savings to be made by installing solar panels.
Unlike the CEOs, bankers and politicians of today, he does not impose austerity from a luxury yacht. He is not willing to spend frivolous money on himself any more than he would on others. This attitude, which seems mean-spirited, can also be highly radical. If everyone consumed like Scrooge today then capitalism would collapse within a few weeks, which makes him a strange choice of hero for those on the neo-liberal right...
AND THE BEATING GOES ON...
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
88 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations

Why Scrooge is an anti-capitalist hero, bravely resisting the commercialisation of Christmas
Demeter
Dec 2014
#9
Chinese Banks Hemorrhaging Deposits, 1st Quarterly Drop Since 1999; Banks Offer iPhones, Even Cars
Demeter
Dec 2014
#10
thanks for that, bread. I wasn't into opera until recently. A family member is training to be an
antigop
Dec 2014
#47
Elizabeth Warren’s real beef with Antonio Weiss: What her fight against him is actually about
Demeter
Dec 2014
#17
Saudis Tell Shale Industry It Will Break Them, Plans to Keep Pumping Even at $20 a Barrel
Demeter
Dec 2014
#23
I'm not saying it's true, but those crazy guys at CIA will do anything, repeatedly
Demeter
Dec 2014
#69
How the U.S. Government Botched Its Multibillion-Dollar Plan to Beat Childhood Disease
xchrom
Dec 2014
#35
Obama Imports and Immunizes Banksters Who Donate to the Democratic Party WILLIAM K BLACK
Demeter
Dec 2014
#39
IMF, World Bank Halt Lending to Ukraine – Franklin Templeton $4 Billion Ukraine Bet Goes Bad
Demeter
Dec 2014
#45
Oh, Demeter..."Big Bang Theory" is the ONLY thing I watch on TV. Nerds rock! nt
antigop
Dec 2014
#50