Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
4. Chapter 4: Who guards the guardians? The conflicting interests of investment arbitrators
Wed Jul 1, 2015, 06:32 PM
Jul 2015

FROM Corporate Europe Observatory:Exposing the power of corporate lobbying in the EU

http://corporateeurope.org/trade/2012/11/chapter-4-who-guards-guardians-conflicting-interests-investment-arbitrators

When I wake up at night and think about arbitration, it never ceases to amaze me that sovereign states have agreed to investment arbitration at all [...] Three private individuals are entrusted with the power to review, without any restriction or appeal procedure, all actions of the government, all decisions of the courts, and all laws and regulations emanating from parliament.

Juan Fernández-Armesto, arbitrator from Spain


Investment arbitrators are hidden from public view, barely mentioned in international media. This is perhaps not surprising, given that most people’s eyes glaze over at the mere mention of the words. Yet this small group of elite lawyers have been granted unprecedented power to judge cases that affect millions of people.

When companies sue governments in international arbitration tribunals, investment arbitrators have the power to divert taxpayers’ money to corporations. They can decide to penalise governments for ensuring people’s human rights to health, access to water or electricity as well as the right to a healthy environment. This field of law is certainly not short of technocratic detail and obtuse legalese, but it has a much broader relevance when we understand the role that this group of lawyers play in decisions that affect ordinary people’s lives.

Advocates claim an international arbitration system is needed because national courts are not sufficiently neutral. They say that only international arbitration courts can provide the neutral ground to deal with investors’ concerns. That means that investment arbitrators become the guardians of investment arbitration, and confidence in the system is based on their perceived independence. Yet investment arbitrators are hardly neutral guardians, who stand above the law. In fact, they are crucial actors in the arbitration industry, with a financial interest in the existence of investment arbitration. Arbitrators, to a far greater degree than judges, have a financial and professional stake in the system. They earn handsome rewards for their services. Unlike judges, there is no flat salary, no cap on financial remuneration.

Arbitrators are people to whom others entrust their wealth and welfare.

William W. Park, investment arbitrator


Arbitrators’ fees can range from US$375 to US$700 per hour depending on where the arbitration takes place. How much an arbitrator earns per case will depend on the case’s length and complexity, but for a US$100 million dispute, arbitrators could earn on average up to US$350,0005. It can be far more. The presiding arbitrator in the case between Chevron and Texaco v. Ecuador, received US$939,0006. In another case, the Tribunal president billed for 719 hours at an hourly rate of US$660 plus VAT...

MORE AT LINK

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Why it's not over (bonus toon) Tansy_Gold Jul 2015 #1
This is why I never go south of the Ohio River, if I can help it Demeter Jul 2015 #2
I drove the length of Alabama during the Judge Roy Moore flapdoodle in 2003 Warpy Jul 2015 #7
Oh yeah, I remember driving through Georgia in 2004. Especially around Macon. Fuddnik Jul 2015 #9
The economic plan that could save America (but scares conservative billionaires senseless) Demeter Jul 2015 #3
Chapter 4: Who guards the guardians? The conflicting interests of investment arbitrators Demeter Jul 2015 #4
THE GREEKS SPEAK (AND FRIENDS OF GREEKS) Demeter Jul 2015 #5
Ambrose Evans-Pritchard, in Athens DemReadingDU Jul 2015 #8
Putin extends Western food ban for one year Demeter Jul 2015 #6
JUNE 10 Here are all the CEOs and politicians going to the top secret Bilderberg Conference Demeter Jul 2015 #10
Pillage and Class Polarization: The Rise of “Criminal Capitalism” By James Petras Demeter Jul 2015 #11
MICHAEL HUDSON ON RUSSIA, UKRAINE, AND THE WEST Demeter Jul 2015 #12
Morales: EU Should Free Itself from Shackles of IMF Demeter Jul 2015 #13
US Allocates 'Democracy Funds' for Cuba JUNE 13 Demeter Jul 2015 #14
U.S., Venezuela launch quiet diplomacy to ease acrimony BE CAREFUL, VENEZUELA! Demeter Jul 2015 #15
ACE buys upmarket Chubb in biggest ever insurance takeover Demeter Jul 2015 #16
DOJ subpoenas airlines over keeping ticket prices high Demeter Jul 2015 #17
Republican senators demand liquidation plan for U.S. Ex-Im Bank Demeter Jul 2015 #18
E.U. slams the door on talks with Greece before Sunday referendum Demeter Jul 2015 #19
Greece just defaulted, but the danger is only beginning Demeter Jul 2015 #20
Michael Hudson and Bill Black interview DemReadingDU Jul 2015 #21
OFF WITH THEIR HEADS! Demeter Jul 2015 #23
TY! nt mother earth Jul 2015 #24
ETA News Release: Unemployment Insurance Weekly Claims Report (07/02/2015) mahatmakanejeeves Jul 2015 #22
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»STOCK MARKET WATCH -- Thu...»Reply #4