Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Demeter

(85,373 posts)
21. Europe’s Many Economic Disasters PAUL KRUGMAN CHEERS US UP
Fri Jul 3, 2015, 04:58 PM
Jul 2015
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/03/opinion/paul-krugman-europes-many-disasters.html

It’s depressing thinking about Greece these days, so let’s talk about something else, O.K.? Let’s talk, for starters, about Finland, which couldn’t be more different from that corrupt, irresponsible country to the south. Finland is a model European citizen; it has honest government, sound finances and a solid credit rating, which lets it borrow money at incredibly low interest rates.

It’s also in the eighth year of a slump that has cut real gross domestic product per capita by 10 percent and shows no sign of ending. In fact, if it weren’t for the nightmare in southern Europe, the troubles facing the Finnish economy might well be seen as an epic disaster. And Finland isn’t alone. It’s part of an arc of economic decline that extends across northern Europe through Denmark — which isn’t on the euro, but is managing its money as if it were — to the Netherlands. All of these countries are, by the way, doing much worse than France, whose economy gets terrible press from journalists who hate its strong social safety net, but it has actually held up better than almost every other European nation except Germany.

And what about southern Europe outside Greece? European officials have been hyping the recovery in Spain, which did everything it was supposed to do and whose economy has finally started to grow again and even to create jobs. But success, European-style, means an unemployment rate that is still almost 23 percent and real income per capita that is still down 7 percent from its pre-crisis level. Portugal has also obediently implemented harsh austerity — and is 6 percent poorer than it used to be.

Why are there so many economic disasters in Europe? Actually, what’s striking at this point is how much the origin stories of European crises differ. Yes, the Greek government borrowed too much. But the Spanish government didn’t — Spain’s story is all about private lending and a housing bubble. And Finland’s story doesn’t involve debt at all. It is, instead, about weak demand for forest products, still a major national export, and the stumbles of Finnish manufacturing, in particular of its erstwhile national champion Nokia.

What all of these economies have in common, however, is that by joining the eurozone they put themselves into an economic straitjacket. Finland had a very severe economic crisis at the end of the 1980s — much worse, at the beginning, than what it’s going through now. But it was able to engineer a fairly quick recovery in large part by sharply devaluing its currency, making its exports more competitive. This time, unfortunately, it had no currency to devalue. And the same goes for Europe’s other trouble spots.

Does this mean that creating the euro was a mistake? Well, yes. But that’s not the same as saying that it should be eliminated now that it exists. The urgent thing now is to loosen that straitjacket. This would involve action on multiple fronts, from a unified system of bank guarantees to a willingness to offer debt relief for countries where debt is the problem. It would also involve creating a more favorable overall environment for countries trying to adjust to bad luck by renouncing excessive austerity and doing everything possible to raise Europe’s underlying inflation rate — currently below 1 percent — at least back up to the official target of 2 percent.

But there are many European officials and politicians who are opposed to anything and everything that might make the euro workable, who still believe that all would be well if everyone exhibited sufficient discipline. And that’s why there is even more at stake in Sunday’s Greek referendum than most observers realize.


One of the great risks if the Greek public votes yes — that is, votes to accept the demands of the creditors, and hence repudiates the Greek government’s position and probably brings the government down — is that it will empower and encourage the architects of European failure. The creditors will have demonstrated their strength, their ability to humiliate anyone who challenges demands for austerity without end. And they will continue to claim that imposing mass unemployment is the only responsible course of action.

What if Greece votes no? This will lead to scary, unknown terrain. Greece might well leave the euro, which would be hugely disruptive in the short run. But it will also offer Greece itself a chance for real recovery. And it will serve as a salutary shock to the complacency of Europe’s elites. Or to put it a bit differently, it’s reasonable to fear the consequences of a “no” vote, because nobody knows what would come next. But you should be even more afraid of the consequences of a “yes,” because in that case we do know what comes next — more austerity, more disasters and eventually a crisis much worse than anything we’ve seen so far.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

ON PATRIOTISM Robert Reich Demeter Jul 2015 #1
Reich is a dirty commie hippie! Fuddnik Jul 2015 #2
It's not enough to drone them? Demeter Jul 2015 #4
Somebody makes a lot of money DemReadingDU Jul 2015 #36
Which States Are the Most Patriotic (And Which Are the Least) By Janet Allon Demeter Jul 2015 #3
Don't even know what to think about this one... MattSh Jul 2015 #5
If he's claiming to be mentally ill, I'd agree Demeter Jul 2015 #11
Organizational capacity and the Greek Referendum by Lambert Strether Naked Capitalism Demeter Jul 2015 #6
Greek Court Allows Vote on Bailout Package Demeter Jul 2015 #20
Expect Greek vote 1 AM MONDAY EDT ETA of Greek referendum result Demeter Jul 2015 #40
Great OP, thread, all of it, what fitting way to celebrate the July 4th holiday, Greece, the mother earth Jul 2015 #48
This is very unsettling. nt mother earth Jul 2015 #49
Europe has suffered a reputational catastrophe in Greece: unable to manage its basic moral responsib Demeter Jul 2015 #7
AND AS FOR THE EU Demeter Jul 2015 #8
PALLAS ATHENA Demeter Jul 2015 #9
VIDEO AND MORE AT LINK Demeter Jul 2015 #10
What No One Is Talking About When They Talk About Greece Demeter Jul 2015 #12
Rise in Use of Firewood to Heat Homes Causing Deforestation Demeter Jul 2015 #13
How we survive a Greek tragedy Demeter Jul 2015 #14
BARTER IS BACK Demeter Jul 2015 #15
We can’t print drachmas, says Greece’s finance minister Demeter Jul 2015 #16
Paypal Shuts Down in Greece - Bitcoin Still Operates Demeter Jul 2015 #22
Paypal has never been for the people. snot Jul 2015 #70
MEANWHILE, BACK IN THE USSR...I MEAN, USA Demeter Jul 2015 #17
Americans Not In The Labor Force Jumps By 640,000 To 93.6 Million (Participation Rate Drops To 1977 Demeter Jul 2015 #18
June’s unemployment dip means more Americans leaving the workforce Demeter Jul 2015 #23
Why you can't believe the unemployment numbers Demeter Jul 2015 #24
Our Spoiled-Brat Economy Demeter Jul 2015 #26
Only 44 Percent Of U.S. Adults Are Employed For 30 Or More Hours Per Week FEBRUARY Demeter Jul 2015 #57
This message was self-deleted by its author Demeter Jul 2015 #58
China's Boom Has World Bank Worried By William Pesek Demeter Jul 2015 #19
Big Trouble In Big China: Shanghai Stock Market Index Drops 5.77% In One Day (And 29% Since June 12) Demeter Jul 2015 #43
Europe’s Many Economic Disasters PAUL KRUGMAN CHEERS US UP Demeter Jul 2015 #21
The Bill: Germany Faces Billions in Losses If Greece Goes Bust Demeter Jul 2015 #25
HOMERIC GREEK IDEALS (STUDY GUIDE) Demeter Jul 2015 #27
I truly wonder if the Enlightenment ever reached Germany Demeter Jul 2015 #28
Been thinking a lot lately about this very topic FlatBaroque Jul 2015 #29
Indeed so DemReadingDU Jul 2015 #35
Hell, yeah! nt mother earth Jul 2015 #46
Musical Interlude hamerfan Jul 2015 #30
Greece's National Anthem Demeter Jul 2015 #31
Anti-Americanism provides big boost to Russia's small IT businesses - CSMonitor.com MattSh Jul 2015 #32
Sell Unmarked GMO Products and Jail Awaits MattSh Jul 2015 #33
Russia Science & Technology Roundup, June 2015 MattSh Jul 2015 #34
Meanwhile, back in America Demeter Jul 2015 #37
Alexandria Uses Block Chain to Preserve World's Knowledge Demeter Jul 2015 #38
Metadata Doesn't Always Mean Metadata: New Snowden Revelations Reveal Government Spying Went Much De Demeter Jul 2015 #39
EMU Periphery Watch: Investors Hold Fast Ahead of Greece Vote Demeter Jul 2015 #41
IS IT A JOKE, OR IS IT REAL? Demeter Jul 2015 #42
Oh, thats real, for sure! Fuddnik Jul 2015 #51
What Do We Learn from the Latest Monthly Employment Report?: DeLong FAQ by Brad DeLong Demeter Jul 2015 #44
Title perfect and stellar intro bread_and_roses Jul 2015 #45
Bernie Sanders on the situation in Greece & the IMF...unprecedented stance. mother earth Jul 2015 #47
The Pope on the banks bread_and_roses Jul 2015 #50
1776 Demeter Jul 2015 #52
Some intrepid soul has posted the whole thing Demeter Jul 2015 #53
Famous Last Words. " &$%@ the alligators!!!!!" Fuddnik Jul 2015 #54
Well, it was Texas Demeter Jul 2015 #55
Greece Again Demeter Jul 2015 #56
Greek bank official dismisses 'haircut' report as "baseless" Demeter Jul 2015 #59
9 Myths Of Greek Crisis: Insider’s take on the conventional wisdom to ignore. By James K. Galbraith Demeter Jul 2015 #61
Why Greece and Germany just don’t get along, in 15 charts Demeter Jul 2015 #62
Stanford scholar debunks long-held beliefs about economic growth in ancient Greece Demeter Jul 2015 #63
Excellent article by an excellent economist! Kudos to Galbraith for laying it out for us, mother earth Jul 2015 #66
Greek voters angry at media & creditors, scare-mongering campaign seems to backfire DemReadingDU Jul 2015 #64
today's toon DemReadingDU Jul 2015 #65
U.S. trade bill with EU includes landmark anti-BDS provisions Demeter Jul 2015 #60
That's a wrap, folks. Now we wait for the election results Demeter Jul 2015 #67
the trend is slowing, but still the lead widens. nearly 77% in; 61.60% OXI. magical thyme Jul 2015 #68
86.16% reporting; 61.53% OXI magical thyme Jul 2015 #69
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Economy»Weekend Economists Salute...»Reply #21