Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

kurt_cagle

(534 posts)
16. Caricatures
Sat Feb 4, 2012, 02:32 PM
Feb 2012

I think that's a good point, and it's been a cause of concern to me for a while.

It's hard for any work of fiction to avoid caricaturing, and perhaps harder in television than for most media. There you have to establish multiple characters, create a scenario, build up an engaging plot and bring the story to a conclusion within 46 minutes. For many TV writers, this means a reliance upon tropes and conventions to fill in some of the details, it means that the characters need to be all surface (deep introspection, while vital, is boring) and it often means that interactions have to be intense and quick, while in real life that's actually very seldom the case. The actors need to be not just pretty or plain but beautiful or grotesque, because a lot of television bypasses the higher orders of the brain and goes for those biologic cues that we look for at an animal level, such as the presence or absence of symmetry or enhanced sexual characteristics, in order to determine the possible health of a mate. (And lets not forget that more eyeballs on a woman's breasts or a man's chest will also mean more eyeballs on the car commercial that follows, with those sleek curves or rugged features molded in steel rather than flesh).

The problem with that is that after a while the viewers of these caricatures cannot distinguish them from his or her own life. We don't measure up, which fuels our desire for the material products which can then be pitched to become more like these caricatures). We emulate the shallowness because people reading in libraries are boring to watch, even if they are writing the next great novel or researching a case (indeed, about the only time I can think of showing a person reading a book is when someone is selling a vacation on a beach). It becomes a feedback loop.

I would argue that I don't think books are AS bad, though they do pick up that bias. The need for caricature is still there, but what appears perfectly normal in a television series can seem extraordinarily shallow and empty in a book. Characters that might seem funny in the canned laugh-track world of TV comedy become pathetic, snarky and mean when the same is translated to a novel. That's one reason why most avid readers tend not to watch that much television. eBooks right now are facing some of that because a lot of writers in that media are coming from their expectations of television, but I think this is a transitional stage.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

You bring up a very good point. Justice wanted Feb 2012 #1
I have a problem with fiction in general justiceischeap Feb 2012 #2
I know exactly what you mean. It isn't just heroes it has been in movies since they started. Justice wanted Feb 2012 #3
i stopped reading in the 80's cause of the protrayals of women seabeyond Feb 2012 #7
i read a new author kindle book and loved it. truly a kick ass main female character seabeyond Feb 2012 #5
since getting a kindle, i have received a lot of free or cheap books from new authors. seabeyond Feb 2012 #4
I just think it's sad justiceischeap Feb 2012 #6
Some Thoughts From a Writer kurt_cagle Feb 2012 #8
Your book sounds interesting and something I'd probably like reading justiceischeap Feb 2012 #9
Rescue kurt_cagle Feb 2012 #12
love this. and this is what i was thinking reading thru this thread. seabeyond Feb 2012 #14
I totally get that fiction is not real life and often real life is quite boring justiceischeap Feb 2012 #15
Ah yes, the Unholy Triangle kurt_cagle Feb 2012 #17
except you and i are seeing ourselves about the same, and over time and experience, conclude about seabeyond Feb 2012 #13
i think a writer needs to get past the concern of defeminizing and this is why... seabeyond Feb 2012 #11
Yeah, sadly it isn't even surprising to me. redqueen Feb 2012 #10
Caricatures kurt_cagle Feb 2012 #16
I generally base my characters off real people, but tone them down. ZombieHorde Feb 2012 #18
So interesting libodem Feb 2012 #19
Are you a reader? Are you a feminist? If so, you have something to add to the conversation justiceischeap Feb 2012 #20
Yes, I love to read libodem Feb 2012 #21
that is a fun series. stopped reading about 12, 13. seabeyond Feb 2012 #23
I would just like to add this to the thread. Lunacee2012 Feb 2012 #22
It happens with a lot of female writers too justiceischeap Feb 2012 #24
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Feminists»Overheard on another boar...»Reply #16