1 - They're flat out stingy, and always have been. They simply don't put a lot of money into these movies, and until they do the G movies will never make it beyond cult status. I don't mind that, but I do long to see at least one Godzilla movie done with top notch FX...and actually cast Godzilla as Godzilla. A full movie using just a CGI Godzilla would cost a lot, even for an American studio. This clip is an awesome tease of what it might look like though.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEEXydQc9KE2 - Tradition. The guy in the suit technique, like their animation, is much more highly respected as an art form in Japan than over here. To them, this tradition in the Godzilla movies is part of the charm of them. It's one of the reasons they keep bringing back so many actors and actresses over and over, like Akira Takarada, who was in the first movie, the last movie, and a ton in between. It's both tongue in cheek in a sense, and a homage to the older G movies at the same time.
I'm torn. I'd love to see a killer CGI Godzilla, but the miniature/suit stuff is still really appealing to me as well. I do think that it's just about reached it's limit though, as CGI just allows for much more dynamic shots, and we're seeing a lot of the same shots in the new G movies that were done back in the 60's, and basically using the exact same techniques.
I think to breathe life into the series when it comes back they're going to have to take a bigger chance than they usually do. I think they make a mistake by releasing one movie every year, and they should make one every two years with twice the budget. The movie will be better and less rushed (Megaguirus has some shots that were clearly hurried, for instance), plus it would build up more excitement and demand between films. And there clearly is a demand lately. Since Final Wars there's been a spate of big monster movies. Time for the King to reclaim the throne, and I ain't talking about Elvis. :)
Here's a couple of non-related quick tidbits that are cool. Tarantino was asked right after the Kill Bill movies what movie franchise he'd most like to take over, and he said Godzilla, which triggers all kinds of wild ideas. And second, in the first Kill Bill when Uma Thurman's character is on the jet looking down at Tokyo, that's a set from one of the Godzilla movies that gets used for various city shots in other Toho films.
I need a life. :rofl: