http://www.shatnerdvdclub.com/html/sounds ridiculous on its face, but I joined, and I have not been disappointed. He's picked out a bunch of movies that I wouldn't have even heard of, but really enjoyed so far.
Well, one exception: My first selection was the werewolf film Gingersnaps, which was great. but it came with a bonus "werewolf" movie, Wolves of Wall Street, about werewolf stockbrokers. Easily the worst movie I've ever seen.
So far, I've recieved Gingersnaps, Immortel, Close Your Eyes, and Crazy As Hell. All pretty interesting movies.
It's $48 for a year, and you keep everything. I highly recommend it.