Reply #28: For the purposes of the law of return, they are Jews... [View All]

[shaayecanaan]

and if a buddhist Jew or secular Jew or communist Jew still counts as a Jew then I can't see how believing that the temple mount is in Nablus rather than Jerusalem could disqualify you.

Moreover, from the perspective of a Palestinian, they are clearly Jews, in the same way that from the perspective of a Jew, a Jehovahs' witness clearly counts as a Christian.