Zhade
(1000+ posts)
Send PM |
Profile |
Ignore
|
Sun Oct-10-10 11:41 PM
Original message |
Science and religion aren't friends |
|
http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/forum/2010-10-11-column11_ST_N.htmScience and religion aren't friendsReligion in America is on the defensive.
Atheist books such as The God Delusion and The End of Faith have, by exposing the dangers of faith and the lack of evidence for the God of Abraham, become best-sellers. Science nibbles at religion from the other end, relentlessly consuming divine explanations and replacing them with material ones. Evolution took a huge bite a while back, and recent work on the brain has shown no evidence for souls, spirits, or any part of our personality or behavior distinct from the lump of jelly in our head. We now know that the universe did not require a creator. Science is even studying the origin of morality. So religious claims retreat into the ever-shrinking gaps not yet filled by science. And, although to be an atheist in America is still to be an outcast, America's fastest-growing brand of belief is non-belief.
But faith will not go gentle. For each book by a "New Atheist," there are many others attacking the "movement" and demonizing atheists as arrogant, theologically ignorant, and strident. The biggest area of religious push-back involves science. Rather than being enemies, or even competitors, the argument goes, science and religion are completely compatible friends, each devoted to finding its own species of truth while yearning for a mutually improving dialogue.
As a scientist and a former believer, I see this as bunk. Science and faith are fundamentally incompatible, and for precisely the same reason that irrationality and rationality are incompatible. They are different forms of inquiry, with only one, science, equipped to find real truth. And while they may have a dialogue, it's not a constructive one. Science helps religion only by disproving its claims, while religion has nothing to add to science.
More at the link. Great piece that defines the disconnect. I find myself in full agreement, and like the way it lays out the facts without insulting believers. I hope the resulting discussion here can stay on that tack -- on both sides. (Also, I'm amazed this appeared in USA Today of all places! It's a good sign for us nonreligious folks.)
|