Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner

[Faygo Kid]

Source: New York Times

By FRANK RICH

AND so: just how far have we come?

As a rough gauge last week, I watched a movie I hadn’t seen since it came out when I was a teenager in 1967. Back then “Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner” was Hollywood’s idea of a stirring call for racial justice. The premise: A young white woman falls madly in love with a black man while visiting the University of Hawaii and brings him home to San Francisco to get her parents’ blessing. Dad, a crusading newspaper publisher, and Mom, a modern art dealer, are wealthy white liberals — Katharine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy, no less — so surely there can be no problem. Complications ensue before everyone does the right thing.

Though the film was a box-office smash and received 10 Oscar nominations, even four decades ago it was widely ridiculed as dated by liberal critics. The hero, played by the first black Hollywood superstar, Sidney Poitier, was seen as too perfect and too “white” — an impossibly handsome doctor with Johns Hopkins and Yale on his résumé and a Nobel-worthy career fighting tropical diseases in Africa for the World Health Organization. What couple would not want him as a son-in-law? “He’s so calm and sure of everything,” says his fiancée. “He doesn’t have any tensions in him.” She is confident that every single one of their biracial children will grow up to “be president of the United States and they’ll all have colorful administrations.”

What a strange movie to confront in 2008. As the world knows, Barack Obama’s own white mother and African father met at the University of Hawaii. In “Dreams From My Father,” he even imagines the awkward dinner where his mother introduced her liberal-ish parents to her intended in 1959. But what’s most startling about this archaic film is the sole element in it that proves inadvertently contemporary. Faced with a black man in the mold of the Poitier character — one who appears “so calm” and without “tensions” — white liberals can make utter fools of themselves. When Joe Biden spoke of Obama being “clean” and “articulate,” he might have been recycling Spencer Tracy’s lines of 41 years ago. . . .


Read more: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/02/opinion/02rich.html?ref=opinion

---

[plaintiff]

1. It was, and still is, a wonderful movie.

Yep.

[Faygo Kid]

2. How could a movie with Sidney Poitier, Katherine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy NOT be wonderful?

All three are luminous. I LOVED the interview this summer in AARP The Magazine with Sidney Poitier. Best interview all year.

[elleng]

3. Wasn't it Tracy's last?

.

[Old Codger]

4. Yes

Spencer Tracy died 3 weeks after completion I believe.

[yellodawgDem]

6. YOU GUYS ARE MISSING THE POINT

we still have a long way to go for true equality and acceptance. Look deep inside yourself and ask yourself what if. What would you do if your son or daughter brought home a african american, educated, intelligent, classy, worldly and sophisticated, could or would you handle it. Tough question I know, but sooner or later it may be one that you or I may have to confront.

[Mojorabbit]

7. I dated an african american

when I was sixteen in the early seventies. My parents were not thrilled about it but they did not forbid me to see him either. They let me work out my own relationships.

[BoneDaddy]

9. Yeah I have no problem with it at all

if my son's dated someone from the black community, as long as they were smart, kind and had some class.

[Demeter]

10. I Was Seriously Involved, But He Backed Out

Heart still hurts, although he died 4 years ago....divorced from the bimbo he did marry.

[Doctor_J]

5. Pls edit subject line to include Frank Rich

tnx

[MonteLukast]

8. Obama always did remind me of Sidney Poitier...

The same elegance and sophistication.

And they even both grew up in tropical island locales!

[jimmybama]

11. Not me

I think Obama reminds me of Denzel Washington with his cool!!