The whole issue of "pre-emptive defense/war"...aka attack/invasion... has bothered me for sometime.. The thinking, as I understand him is to destroy today, what "might" be trouble tomorrow..
Using his logic, we should all have our teeth pulled today, so we don't develop cavaties tomorrow.. We should never marry, because someday a spouse will die or we may divorce.. We should never drive a car, because someday we might have an auto accident.. We shold never have children, because they may grow up to be horrible people, or they may not love us.. etc etc etc
We did this before... to the Native Americans..
Shoshone Sacred Grounds
By Payton Lee
https://www.authorsden.com/visit/viewshortstory.asp?AuthorID=9292Sunday, August 18, 2002
snip....
While we laud the Shoshone Sacagawea, there is a battle going on in a small location north and west of Franklin, Idaho. It is the northwestern Shoshone nation trying to obtain sacred land. It is the sacred land where
138 years ago a California militia Colonel named Patrick Edward Connor gave his infantry and cavalry of over two hundred orders to 'take no prisoners and remember nits grow into lice.' This order began a four-hour slaughter at 6:00 a.m. in the morning as the sleepy peaceful people woke at their winter camp at Bear River on January 29, 1863. Nearly the entire camp of 400 warriors, old men, old women, women, children, and babies were obliterated. The undisciplined militia raped the women and young girls. When they were finished with the women, the militia split their heads open with axes or shot them. Any children and babies who were found alive or wounded were likewise clubbed to death, axed, or shot. The militia acted in the most barbarous ways and when the battle was over plundered the camp. The militia took the Shoshone ponies, food, warm skins, and buffalo robes. What this militia could not take with them were scattered and walked upon. The standing tepees were burnt to the ground.
The militias under Connor were not yet finished with their vicious slaughters. The militia had taken Chief Bear Hunter captive and after binding him, the chief was kicked, whipped, and shot. Chief Bear Hunter was a proud and brave chief who did not utter a word or issue a cry of mercy under his torment. This so infuriated the militia; one of them heated a bayonet and thrust it through Chief Bear Hunter's ears.
In the evening, the militia loaded their dead for burial and wounded for care. The slaughtered Shoshone men, women, and children were left on the field for crows and wolves to devour. At night a surviving chief, Sagwitch found his dead wife and two of his four children dead. One child was missing and an infant daughter who survived was placed in a cradleboard and hung on a tree with the hope someone would find her and take care of her. A two-year-old son did survive and lived to tell the story to the young Shoshone.
snip.....
Web Site: Bear River Spirit