Since 1824, a sitting President has sought reelection 26
times. 17 won their bids for reelection, and nine lost. Here’s
how George W. Bush did compared to them, first based on the
margins of victory/loss, and then on the percentage of the
electoral vote.
Popular Vote
Incumbents Who Won
Year Incumbent Margin
1924 Calvin Coolidge 25.22%
1936 Franklin Roosevelt 24.25%
1972 Richard Nixon 23.15%
1964 Lyndon Johnson 22.58%
1904 Theodore Roosevelt 18.83%
1984 Ronald Reagan 18.22%
1832 Andrew Jackson 16.81%
1956 Dwight Eisenhower 15.40%
1872 Ulysses Grant 11.80%
1864 Abraham Lincoln 10.06%
1940 Franklin Roosevelt 9.95%
1996 Bill Clinton 8.52%
1944 Franklin Roosevelt 7.49%
1900 William McKinley 6.13%
1948 Harry Truman 4.48%
1916 Woodrow Wilson 3.12%
2004 George W. Bush 3.04%
Incumbents Who Lost
1888 Grover Cleveland (*) 0.80%
1976 Gerald Ford -2.06%
1892 Benjamin Harrison -3.01%
1992 George Bush -5.56%
1840 Martin Van Buren -6.07%
1980 Jimmy Carter -9.74%
1828 John Q. Adams -12.34%
1932 Herbert Hoover -17.76%
1912 William Taft (+) -18.67%
**********
Electoral Vote
Incumbents Who Won
Year Name EV %
1936 Franklin Roosevelt 98.49%
1984 Ronald Reagan 97.58%
1972 Richard Nixon 96.65%
1864 Abraham Lincoln 90.60%
1964 Lyndon Johnson 90.33%
1956 Dwight Eisenhower 86.06%
1940 Franklin Roosevelt 84.56%
1944 Franklin Roosevelt 81.36%
1872 Ulysses Grant 78.14%
1832 Andrew Jackson 76.04%
1924 Calvin Coolidge 71.94%
1904 Theodore Roosevelt 70.59%
1996 Bill Clinton 70.45%
1900 William McKinley 65.32%
1948 Harry Truman 57.06%
2004 George W. Bush 53.16%
1916 Woodrow Wilson 52.17%
Incumbents Who Lost
1976 Gerald Ford 44.61%
1888 Grover Cleveland (*) 41.90%
1892 Benjamin Harrison 32.66%
1828 John Q. Adams 31.80%
1992 George Bush 31.23%
1840 Martin Van Buren 20.41%
1932 Herbert Hoover 11.11%
1980 Jimmy Carter 9.11%
1912 William Taft (+) 1.51%
(*) Won the popular vote, lost the electoral vote.
(+) The third party candidate, Theodore Roosevelt,
outperformed Taft in both the popular and electoral votes.