courtesy of IranianDemocrat:
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=104&topic_id=716422Flip: In 1992, Dean said, "I don't support the death penalty for two reasons. One, you might have the wrong guy, and, two, the state is like a parent. Parents who smoke cigarettes can't really tell their children not to smoke and be taken seriously. If a state tells you not to murder people, a state shouldn't be in the business of taking people's lives." The Rutland Herald, a Vermont newspaper, says that in those days "Dean was an outspoken opponent of the death penalty."
Flop: In early June 2003, Dean issued a statement declaring, "As governor, I came to believe that the death penalty would be a just punishment for certain, especially heinous crimes, such as the murder of a child or the murder of a police officer. The events of Sept. 11 convinced me that terrorists also deserve the ultimate punishment."
Context: Dean's statement added, "I would instruct my attorney general to seek capital punishment only in very serious cases, including those involving vulnerable victims and those involving terrorism." On June 22, 2003, Dean said on Meet the Press, "The only instances that I support the death penalty are 1) murder of a child, 2) a mass murder like a terrorist, and 3) the shooting of a police officer." He cited a series of 1994 Vermont newspaper articles that documented his rethinking of capital punishment. Dean said the rape-murder of Polly Klaas by a previously convicted sex offender prompted his rethinking. He said he worried that life imprisonment without parole didn't guarantee justice because convicted murderers could still get out on a "technicality." He rejected deterrence (except for cop-killers) and vengeance as arguments for the death penalty. He said he came to support capital punishment because terrorists and child predators are "incapable of being rehabilitated," and "to let these people out is too dangerous."
Flip: On Feb. 28, 1995, Dean said on CNN's Crossfire that Social Security "absolutely" needed to "increase the retirement age." According to a March 3, 1995 Newhouse News Service report on a subsequent Dean breakfast with reporters, "The way to balance the budget, Dean said, is for Congress to cut Social Security, move the retirement age to 70, cut defense, Medicare and veterans pensions, while the states cut almost everything else." In June 2003, Dean said on Meet the Press, "I also would entertain taking the retirement age to 68."
Flop: At a presidential candidate forum on Aug. 5, 2003, Dean said, "I have never favored Social Security retirement at the age of 70, nor do I favor one of 68."
DEAN FLIP-FLOPS ON COMPLETING MISSION IN IRAQ
March 2003: Dean Ducks Troops Question. “ repeatedly declined to say whether he thinks the United States should withdraw its troops immediately from Iraq, as some vocal war opponents urge. Responding to questions before and during the event, Dean declined to call for the troops’ return, saying he didn’t know the implications for geopolitics and soldiers’ safety and wasn’t privy to intelligence on the ground in Iraq. ‘I didn’t get us into this,’ Dean said. ‘Unfortunately, I’m not president now and I can’t get us out of this.’” (Joanna Weiss, “Dean Ducks Prescription For Quitting Iraq,” The Boston Globe, 3/27/03)
Dean Then Berated Bush For Suggesting American Troops Could Come In 18 Months. “If the President thinks our troops will be out in 18 months, he is smoking something he forgot about when he was at Yale.” (Rebecca Cook, “Howard Dean Rallies Supporters In Seattle,” The Associated Press, 5/15/03)
September 1: Dean Said U.S. Should Not Pull Troops Out Of Iraq. “We can’t leave Iraq. We can’t pull out, because if we do that, chaos ensues or else a fundamentalist Shiite regime may arise with undo Iranian influence, both of which would be more dangerous than Saddam Hussein.” (Howard Dean On CNN’s “Crossfire Goes Inside Politics,” 9/1/03)
ONLY THREE DAYS LATER: In Debate, Dean Said Our Troops Should Come Home From Iraq. DEAN: “We need more troops. They’re going to be foreign troops, as they should have been in the first place, not American troops. Ours need to come home.” (Democrat Presidential Candidates Debate, Albuquerque, NM, 9/4/03)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPS OVER AMERICAN LABOR STANDARDS
July 2003: Dean Called For Strict American Labor Standards For International Trade. “Unlike U.S. Rep. Dennis Kucinich of Ohio, Dean doesn’t want to get rid of the North American Free Trade Agreement. ‘This trade is important to America. It’s important for our national defense,’ Dean said. ‘But we need the same labor standards in Mexico and China as you have in the United States, and the same environmental standards.’” (Lynn Okamoto, “Dean Calls Economy Top Issue For 2004 Race,” The Des Moines Register, 7/19/03)
Dean Backpedaled In Debate, Saying International Standards Could Work. LIEBERMAN: “ay I say just briefly that Governor Dean … referred to American standards, not international standards.” DEAN: “Either is fine with me.” LIEBERMAN: “Well, then that’s a reassuring change of position.” (Democrat Presidential Candidates Debate, Albuquerque, NM, 9/4/03)
…To an Ever-Growing List of Dean Flip-Flops:
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON PUBLIC FINANCING OF HIS 2004 CAMPAIGN
Summer 2003 Public Financing Flip-Flop: Dean “backed away from his pledge to adhere to spending limits, saying some advisers want to explore opting out of the Watergate-era public financing system because of his sudden fund-raising success. … ‘Could we change our mind? Sure,’ he said. … “Dean signed a letter to the promising to abide by the program’s rules, including its spending limits.” (Ron Fournier, “Dean Pulls Back On Spending Limits Pledge,” The Associated Press, 8/15/03)
DEAN ALSO FLIP-FLOPPED ON PUBLIC FINANCING OF HIS 2000 CAMPAIGN!
July 2000 Public Financing Flip: “Gov. Howard Dean is challenging his Republican opponents to accept a $300,000 campaign spending cap even if a federal judge overturns the limit. … ‘This law is important in restoring public faith in the election process,’ Dean said in a prepared statement. ‘Vermonters need to know that their small donations are just as important as a $1,000 check from a multi-national corporation or PAC (political action committee).’ Dean said he was at a financial disadvantage, first because he had a lower spending limit as an incumbent, but also because he faced two challengers who were likely to have at least $300,000 apiece.” (“Dean Challenges Republicans To Spending Limits,” The Associated Press, 7/21/00)
August 2000 Public Financing Flop: “Gov. Howard Dean abandoned public funding for his re-election campaign, saying he couldn’t take the chance he would be outspent 4-1 by his Republican opponent. Publicly financed campaigns were part of strict campaign finance reform legislation championed by Dean, who signed it into law in 1997. … Progressive Party gubernatorial candidate Anthony Pollina, the only candidate now using public funding, criticized Dean’s decision. ‘I am not surprised. In some way it shows his true colors,’ Pollina said. ‘Ultimately, it’s a victory for big money and bad for average citizens.’” (Wilson Ring, “Governor Abandons Public Funding,” The Associated Press, 8/18/00)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON LIFTING CUBA EMBARGO
Dean Once Favored Lifting Cuba Embargo, Now Says It Would Be Wrong. “Howard Dean, who sells himself as the presidential campaign’s straightest shooter, is starting to throw voters some curves. … Last weekend, Dean shifted his position on the trade embargo against Cuba. Dean, who had supported rolling back the embargo to foment human rights improvements, said he has become convinced such a move would be unwise. Cuban Americans, who generally support the embargo, are an important voting bloc in several states, including Florida.” (Jim VandeHei, “Dean Invites More Scrutiny By Switching Key Stances,” The Washington Post, 8/30/03)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON YUCCA MOUNTAIN
1996 Governor Dean Yucca Mountain Flip: “I am urging you to support changes in the Nuclear Waste Policy Act that would ensure that the federal government meets its responsibility to electricity consumers to begin accepting spent fuel from commercial power plants in 1998. … Opponents assert that the shipment of nuclear waste is highly unsafe, but the facts prove otherwise. Over the past 30 years, more than 2000 shipments of spent nuclear fuel have been made on the nation’s highways and railways. No shipment has ever resulted in a release of radioactivity or public harm. … I sincerely hope you will support S. 1271 to establish an integrated spent fuel management program that includes a centralized, interim storage facility, continued site characterization of the potential repository at Yucca Mountain in Nevada, and an appropriate transportation system to move spent fuel.” (Gov. Howard Dean, Letter To Sen. Patrick Leahy, 5/1/96)
2003 Candidate Dean Yucca Mountain Flop: REPORTER: “As governor, you supported a plan to store the nation’s waste at Yucca Mountain, Nev. Do you still think this is a good solution?” DEAN: “As governor of Vermont, it was a grand idea because it would get the waste out of Vermont. But now that I’m running for president, I’ve got to reassess it and see what the science looks like.” (Amanda Griscom, “Q&A: Howard Dean On The Environment,” Alternet Website, www.alternet.org, Accessed 6/4/03)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON DEATH PENALTY
“Opportunist” Dean Now Supports The Death Penalty In Some Cases. “Vermont liberals say Dean’s governing history suggests more of a political tactician, a strategic opportunist who will ultimately run a campaign that inspires the middle as well as the left. … Some years back, reversed his opposition to the death penalty and now supports it in some cases.” (Terry M. Neal, “Will The Real Howard Dean Please Stand Up?” Washingtonpost.com, 7/31/03)
In Disastrous ‘Meet The Press’ Appearance, Dean Admitted To Death Penalty Flip-Flop. “An appearance on ‘Meet the Press’ by Dr. Dean on Sunday, arranged by his aides as part of this announcement swing, turned into what even some Dean supporters described today as something of a debacle, highlighting many areas of attacks Dr. Dean would be subject to in a general election or a primary. … Dr. Dean also acknowledged that he had changed his position on the death penalty -- he now supports it in some cases, after once having been a strong opponent …” (Adam Nagourney, “After A Year Campaigning, Dean Officially Enters Race,” The New York Times, 6/24/03)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON FEDERAL MEDICAL LIABILITY REFORM
1994 Federal Medical Liability Reform Flip: DEAN: “We’ve absolutely got to have malpractice reform. Absolutely. And I think it ought to be done at the federal level. In fact, that’s -- I think all 50 governors think that.” (CNN’s “Viewers Call In With Health Care Questions,” 7/18/94)
2002 Federal Medical Liability Reform Flop: DEAN: “As a doctor, I’d love to have all kinds of malpractice reform. That is not the federal government’s business. This administration, for all its talk about states’ prerogatives and local control, doesn’t believe in it. They simply substituted conservative micromanagement for what used to be liberal micromanagement. It’s like gun control. That is a state matter, not a federal matter.” (CNN’s “Capital Gang,” 10/5/02)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON RETIREMENT AGE
1995 Governor Dean Retirement Age Flip: DEAN: “Secondly, I am very pleased to hear Bob Packwood because I absolutely agree we need to … increase the retirement age. There will be cuts and losses of some benefits, but I believe that Senator Packwood is on exactly the right track. … ” (CNN’s “Crossfire,” 2/28/95)
2003 Candidate DeanRetirement Age Flop: RUSSERT: “Would you raise retirement age to 70?” DEAN: “No. No.” (NBC’s “Meet The Press,” 6/22/03)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON CREATING
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
2002 Homeland Security Flip: Asked what he thought of the creation of the Department of Homeland Security, Dean said: “I don’t have a quarrel with bureaucracy. I wouldn’t do it that way, but I think everyone does their own thing. … I’m not going to attack the President for trying to create a homeland security office—it’s a reasonable thing to do.” (Ann Rostow, “Give ‘Em Hell Howard,” Texas Triangle, 9/5-10/02)
2003 Homeland Security Flop: Howard Dean “‘says the creation of a homeland security department was a mistake and that Tom Ridge is the wrong man for the job.’ In an interview with CQ Homeland Security’s Freedman, Dean said: ‘I would not have created the Department of Homeland Security.’ He added: ‘Creating a new bureaucracy is rarely the actual solution to creating efficiency.’” (“Dean Takes On Homeland Security, Tom Ridge,” The Hotline, 5/21/03)
DEAN FLIP-FLOPPED ON CUTTING SOCIAL SECURITY
1995 Governor Dean Social Security Flip: “The way to balance the budget, Dean said, is for Congress to cut Social Security, move the retirement age to 70, cut defense, Medicare and veterans pensions, while the states cut almost everything else. ‘It would be tough but we could do it,’ he said.” (Miles Benson, “And Politicians Wonder Why They Aren’t Trusted,” Times-Picayune , 3/5/95)
2003 Candidate DeanSocial Security Flop: RUSSERT: “But you would no longer cut Social Security benefits?” DEAN: “But you don’t--no. I’m not ever going to cut Social Security benefits.” (NBC’s “Meet The Press,” 6/22/03)