Battle of the Lennon-McCartney Christmas Songs!

[elperromagico]

Gee, wonder who'll win this one? :shrug:

[Gothic Sponge]

1. Lennon

[villager]

2. But not most of the "Happy Xmas" covers...

And what about the Beatles Fan Club Xmas recordings the Fabs did?

[elperromagico]

3. I dig "Christmas Time (Is Here Again)."

O-U-T spells OUT! :D

[catzies]

6. Now I HAVE to hear the Beatles Fan Club xmas records tonight!

Thanks!!

[justinsb]

4. McCartney's wasn't bad

as Xmas carols go - but comes nowhere close to Lennon's it's like comparing Do They Know It's Christmas (the original Band Aid version) to Winter Wonderland - nothing wrong with Winter Wonderland but it really doesn't say anything meaningful.

[vptpt]

5. Lennon, of course

The McCartney song is annoying.

[LoZoccolo]

7. I heard kind-of a "mash-up"...

...between "Jingle Bells" and "Tommorow Never Knows" yesterday when I was in Potbelly's sub shop. I guess it's from this:

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B00006K0BT/102-1346889-0463313?v=glance

[MrSlayer]

8. John.

[Borgnine]

9. Both.

As always, I can't choose between the two. Lennon's lyrics have more meaning, but McCartney has the catchier tune.

[ET Awful]

10. Lennon's song is probably my all time favorite holiday song of any kind

I just love the song and the sentiment.

[GreenArrow]

11. Paul's song is one of the worst ever

and not just in terms of Christmas songs; it is simply putrid and foul beyond words. I utterly detest it.