John or Paul?

[hsher]

OK, yes, it's flamebait. Let me open with a vote for John.

[Reverend_Smitty]

1. it varies depending on my mood

Right now it's John

[hsher]

2. I got the Anthology

Deep stuff. The bits with Sean make me want to cry.

[Reverend_Smitty]

4. it's such a shame he died when he did

Double Fantasy is such a great album and I'm sure he would still be putting out good stuff today

[GoddessOfGuinness]

3. George...

[SoyCat]

10. Absolutely

[last_texas_dem]

5. I voted for Paul

I love so much stuff by both of them, but Paul always gets such unjustified hatred from so many people that I think, despite the immense success he's had- both solo and with the Beatles, he is actually *underrated* as a musician. And besides, all things considered, I think Paul put out more great music during his solo/post-Beatles career than John did. Of course, John's was tragically cut short, but I'm mostly thinking about their seventies output in making that statement anyway. In terms of their work while with the Beatles, though, I'd give John the edge.

[Bullwinkle925]

6. I'm sure you'll never guess my vote!

:P

[hsher]

7. George

:think:

[donheld]

8. Matthew Mark etc

This gets a bit old. IMHO

[ironflange]

9. What about Pete Best?

Stu Sutcliffe?

[MonkeyFunk]

11. YOKO!

[Nicole]

12. John

However I felt sorry for Ringo, being the only zero on this poll. So...... I voted for him. :rofl:

[hfojvt]

13. gotta go with Paul

You're talking about Paul Wellstone and John Kerry, right?

Definitely Paul.