CNN McCain report card

[apnu]

http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/09/04/rnc.reportcard.mccain/index.html?iref=mpstoryview

P. Begala: B- (score 2.5)
L. Sanchez: A- (score 3.5)
D. Gergen: A (score 4)
R. Martin: D (score 1)
C. Borger: B (score 3)
Average score: 14/5 = 2.8 which is a C+/B-

Visitors grading the speech: 19,126 gave him an average of "D"

(edited to remove an "A" suggesting a grade, which it was not meant to do)

[ErinBerin84]

1. lol...I love Roland Martin.

Gee, Gergen. You graded higher than LESLIE SANCHEZ?? Oh well, at least he really liked Obama's speech too.

[musicblind]

2. I gave him a C

because it made me throw up in my mouth a little less than Palin's big fat F of a speech... but at the same time focused too much on the POW story rather than his actual qualifications. He was less insulting to democrats than I thought he would be after seeing Palin's speech, but he came off a bit wooden and tired. So I don't think the speech went over well with the general public.

I am very very honest in my opinions on such things, so I could not give him an F just because I plan to vote against him in Nov. He did a C. Obama, by comparison did an A+

[AllieB]

3. Gergen has been very critical of Repubs lately, so I'm surprised at his rating.

He's usually one of the few Republicans that doesn't talk out of his ass.