Blast from the past: Presidential Signing Statement for HAVA (circa 2002)

[Kip Humphrey]

The following is the Presidential Signing Statement pursuant to the enactment of HAVA in 2002:

President Signs "Help America Vote Act of 2002"
Statement by the President

Today I have signed into law H.R. 3295, the "Help America Vote Act of 2002." This Act comports with the basic principles set forth in the final report of the bipartisan National Commission on Federal Election Reform, which I endorsed in July of 2001. Consequently, the Act appropriately respects the primacy of State and local governments in the administration of elections, while helping to ensure the integrity and efficiency of voting processes in Federal elections by providing Federal governmental support for that vital endeavor.

Section 203(a)(2) of the Act mandates that members of the congressional leadership submit to the President recommendations of persons to be appointed to the Election Assistance Commission -- an entity, created by the Act, that will exercise significant governmental functions of an executive nature. The executive branch will not construe this provision as establishing the submission of congressional recommendations as a condition precedent to presidential nomination of persons for appointment to the Commission. Such a construction would impose impermissible constraints on presidential power under the Appointments Clause of the Constitution.

Section 203(a)(4) purports to require the President to make appointments to the Commission no later than 120 days after enactment of the new law. As with the provision regarding recommendations for appointment, this deadline unduly circumscribes the presidential appointment power. Moreover, this deadline is practically impossible to satisfy given the time required for the pre-nomination personnel process and confirmation by the full Senate. For these reasons, the executive branch shall interpret this provision as advisory.

Section 902(c) would authorize the Comptroller General, an officer of the legislative branch, to make determinations that would impose binding payment obligations upon entities outside that branch. Because this provision attempts to vest executive functions in the Comptroller General, it violates the constitutional principle of separation of powers.

Finally, the executive branch shall implement section 101, concerning the provision of voting assistance, in a manner consistent with the equal protection requirements of the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution.

GEORGE W. BUSH
THE WHITE HOUSE,
October 29, 2002.

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/10/20021029-5.html

Note that GWB executed 3 recess appointments to the EAC over the 2005 Christmas recess without congressional approval.

For your further consideration:
The text of HAVA as enacted can be found here: http://www.fec.gov/hava/law_ext.txt

The Origins of HAVA: The Carter-Ford National Commission on Election Reform 2001 full report (1.77Mb .PDF)

[MissWaverly]

1. there he goes again, breaking the rules

it's not a bill, it's just a recommendation for me to write into law any way I please.

[bleever]

2. Nominated for some serious scrutiny.

Thanks for posting!

[PeterPan]

3. They were NOT recess appointments to the EAC - that was the FEC

The original EAC was DeForest Soaries (Republican recommended by Senate majority leadership), who resigned and was replaced by donetta Davidson last summer.

Ray Martinez (Democrat recommended by Senate minority leadership)
Paul DeGregorio (Republican recommended by House majority leadership)
and Gracia Hillman (Democrat recommended by House minority leadership)

Marinez announced his resignation in April, effective June 30, but has agreed to stay on until a replacement is chosen by the Senate minority office (Harry Reid).

[Bill Bored]

5. Don't confuse us with the facts please. nt

[Land Shark]

4. Thanks for this info