Forum Name General Discussion
Topic subject Fours statements on the Senate's passage of Bush's FISA bill: Webb, McCaskill, Reid and Rockefeller
Topic URL
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=389x1516764#15167641516764, Fours statements on the Senate's passage of Bush's FISA bill: Webb, McCaskill, Reid and Rockefeller
Posted by ProSense on Sat Aug-04-07 11:55 PM
Sen. Webb Statement on FISA Vote
by: Lowell
Sat Aug 04, 2007 at 17:39:06 PM EDT
From Sen. Webb's office:
Yesterday I supported two measures to amend the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. These measures were considered against the backdrop of heightened concerns from our nation's intelligence community abut the threat of international terrorism. The ramifications of the two amendments before us last night were not political. Instead they related to the urgent demands of national security. I chose to heed those warnings. We now have six months to work in earnest to bring full accountability to the process.
This distinction and the threats to national security were stated clearly by Admiral McConnell as well as four of the eight Democratic members of the Senate Intelligence Committee. These members, Senators Feinstein, Mikulski, Bayh, and Bill Nelson, have extensive experience on intelligence matters and are respected champions of civil rights and liberties. They chose to give significant weight and deference to the intelligence community on FISA reform, and so did I.
There is near uniform, bipartisan agreement on the need to reform FISA to reflect modern telecommunications and information technology. We must do so in a way that safeguards basic civil and constitutional rights. But we must also remember that the terrorist threat to the nation is extremely serious. I remain fully committed to bringing accountability to this process, and to protecting the privacy rights of all Americans.
"I’m not thrilled," said Sen. Claire McCaskill, D-Mo. "There are some changes we need to make to make sure that American citizens are protected. But it's a lot better than a lot of things that have been forced down this Congress' throat right before recesses that trampled on American's liberties."
Senate Democrats worked in good faith with the Director of National Intelligence to produce the Rockefeller-Levin bill that was tough on terrorists, provided much-need oversight of the Attorney General, and did not infringe on the constitutional rights of American citizens. Rather than pass this bill, my Republican colleagues chose to rubberstamp a flawed Administration proposal that fails to provide the accountability needed in light of the Administration’s repeated past mismanagement of key tools in the war on terror. (Senator Harry Reid)
Statement from Senate Intelligence committee chairman Jay Rockefeller:
We all agreed Congress needed to take immediate action in order to help keep the country safe, and the Senate did that tonight.
My opposition to the final bill was based on the fact that it did not include the privacy protections and safeguards American citizens deserve and expect.
We had the opportunity to pass a more careful bill that would have given the DNI the authority he requested, while also protecting the rights of U.S. citizens.
Instead, this bill undermines the FISA Court and concedes unprecedented authority to the Attorney General.
It does contain the six-month sunset that we insisted upon, and that gives us an immediate opportunity and responsibility to come back and strike the right balance.
Interesting!
Printer-friendly format
Email this thread to a friend
Bookmark this thread
(1000+ posts)
Send PM |
Profile |
Ignore
