Ezra Klein: Why Rep. Paul Ryan’s budget plan is so flawed

[ProSense]

Why Rep. Paul Ryan’s budget plan is so flawed

By Ezra Klein

Just over a year ago, I wrote a column praising Rep. Paul Ryan’s Roadmap. I called its ambition “welcome, and all too rare.” I said its dismissal of the status quo was “a point in its favor.” When the inevitable backlash came, I defended Ryan against accusations that he was a fraud, and that technical mistakes in his tax projections should be taken as evidence of dishonesty. I also, for the record, like Ryan personally, and appreciate his policy-oriented approach to politics.

So I believe I have some credibility when I say that the budget Ryan released last week is not courageous or serious or significant. It’s a joke, and a bad one.

For one thing, Ryan’s savings all come from cuts, and at least two-thirds of them come from programs serving the poor. The wealthy, meanwhile, would see their taxes lowered, and the Defense Department would escape unscathed. It is not courageous to attack the weak while supporting your party’s most inane and damaging fiscal orthodoxies. But the problem isn’t just that Ryan’s budget is morally questionable. It also wouldn’t work.

Don’t take it from me. Take it from Robert Reischauer, who directed the Congressional Budget Office from 1989 to 1995 and now leads the Urban Institute. “If this is a competition between Ryan and the Affordable Care Act on realistic approaches to curbing the growth of spending,” Reischauer says, “the Affordable Care Act gets five points and Ryan gets zero.” But Ryan would repeal the Affordable Care Act and replace it with his own wishful plan. In doing so, he makes it harder, not easier, for us to balance the budget.

more

[ProSense]

1. No comment? n/t

[FrenchieCat]

2. Too busy ragging on the President......

to attack Republicans...

or perhaps some just don't have to spine, unless they are attacking their own party. :shrug:

[quaker bill]

3. Possibly,

or perhaps there is just no "fun" in it for some. Of course if one pays too much attention to things like this, you start noticing differences, that according to many, do not exist.

[quaker bill]

4. Living in Florida

I am getting to see what cutting these guys loose looks like. This budget is not the worst they can come up with. Give them the Senate and the Whitehouse and this will be seen as a moderate and centrist approach.