And see replies 29 and 31 above, which link to columns at Mlive.com by a Kalamazoo Gazette reporter claiming Rachel Maddow got her facts wrong, and suggesting what happened wasn't really bad for the people of Benton Harbor.
Rachel's response -- there's video of that in the second column, the one I posted the link to -- focused mainly on the imposition of dictatorial powers by the governor.
The Gazette reporter pointed out the initial grab for the land came under the previous administratzion, and Gov. Granholm had unfortunately sided with the developers. And it was Gov. Granholm who first appointed the emergency financial manager, because of other problems in Benton Harbor. Unfortunately the reporter is right about that, and this is something Granholm should be ashamed of. (Editing to add that Granholm unfortunately played much more of a role in this than I'd realized. I'll add the links to that info at the end of this message, under another link to the site where I found them.)
But it was Gov. Snyder who radically expanded the powers EFMs have (the original emergency financial management law was much more limited in scope).
Which I suspect may involve taking actions to stop the litigation against the development of the park, which has been ongoing.
Those developing the park claim it's taken only 22 acres, leasing those, and more acres than that were added to the park elsewhere, supposedly more than making up for taking that land.
But the land that was taken has the
best views of the lake -- it was the most valuable land there, and they paid only a tiny fraction of its real worth -- and the development is destroying the fragile ecosystem of the dunes.
Worse, the parcels of land added to the park are hazardous, polluted land, and the developers are ignoring some other conditions they agreed to and even put a drainage ditch that wasn't in the earlier plans next to the public picnic area.
Links to the information on this:
http://www.protectjkp.com/That has a link to photos on Flick showing what the park looked like before development
http://michiganmessenger.com/29945/golf-developers-face-new-scrutiny-in-lake-mich-park-privatizationThat is about Benton Harbor City Commissioners complaining about the development doing much more damage to the park than the developers said they did. Those commissioners no longer have ANY power.
http://www.savejeanklockpark.org/StrandofBeach.htmlThat last link has pictures of the drainage ditch carrying runoff of chemicals from the park. The ditch wasn't shown in the original plans, and it was put on public land.
This site also has information on former Gov. Granholm's role in the development, including a pledge to assist Whirlpool with the development.
Link to the page there on the governor's role:
http://www.savejeanklockpark.org/TheGovernorsRole.htmlwith a link to the PDF file showing her May 2006 letter to the CEO of Whirlpool:
http://www.savejeanklockpark.org/files/Granholm_Fettig.pdfI wish I could believe she didn't realize how much damage would be done to the park and the ecosystem, but according to that page she had plenty of warnings about the environmental damage that would be done.
But even though it's shameful that a Democratic governor had sided with the developers against the people of Benton Harbor and against the fragile environment, Rachel is right that the focus of this story now is on the dictatorial powers given to emergency financial managers by the expansion of the EFM law under Rick Snyder. And that will make it much, much easier for corporations and developers to take over public land, destroy ecosystems that had been protected, and create more hazardous conditions on land that the public still owns.