Disqualified
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/disqualified
Fareed Zakaria had a column out yesterday dissecting and demolishing New York Senator Chuck Schumers argument for opposition to the Iran nuclear deal. I wont try to duplicate his arguments on the merits. I dont think I can improve on them. But I have wanted for the last week to address Schumers decision.
As you may know, in the midst of last week's Fox-GOP-Trump debate, Schumer leaked the news that he planned to vote against the deal when it comes before the Senate for review. There are a few things to say about the manner of the leak. As the Senator himself would no doubt agree, no one is more adept, experienced, or desirous of press attention than Schumer. The timing was no accident. It seemed aimed at creating as little splash as possible. Given his status as a prominent, senior, and outspokenly pro-Israel Senator from New York, there is only so much that he could do to limit the impact and reaction. But this was clearly an attempt to do so. And it did get buried to some degree in the Trump Debate/GOP Meltdown/Blood Drama. Schumer has also said that since this is his position, he will of course lobby others to follow his lead. But he has done so not altogether convincingly. Take all this together and I think it is possible that Schumer believes this to be a free vote for him personally - that he can vote in opposition, either knowing that it will pass (sustain a presidential veto) or at least that he wont be blamed for it going down.
Well know after the vote how that all shook out. And in terms of what one makes of Schumer, there is some difference over what the truth turns out to be. Just after Schumers announcement, James Fallows said that it was one thing for Schumer to vote this way himself but if he lifts a finger to lobby other senators against the deal, he should be disqualified from becoming the next Senate Majority/Minority Leader, an office he very much wishes to fill.
I would take it a step further. I think Schumer should be disqualified on the basis of this decision alone. In fact, I would personally find it difficult to ever vote for Schumer again as my Senator, though I doubt hell lose much sleep over that since he is amazingly entrenched as New Yorks senior senator.