Reply #17: The funny thing about rebutting Edwards's biography, too, is that... [View All]

[AP]

...it's not a rebuttable issue. What are they going to say? His biography is a lie? It's not like, "X said this about Medicare" and then X gets to clarify what he said. Kerry and Dean did the only thing they could do with that rebuttal...they just talked about themselves, which, I'm sure, is something the people on the bottom half of that list would have loved to do. It was just a gift to Dean and Kerry, and little else.

But, like you say, the most important issue here is that Edwards wasn't really attacking anyone else, except in a sense that is so tenuous that it's barely rebuttable.