Reply #302: Try again [View All]

[L1A1Rocker]

You write "They've had an opportunity to do so and they will again. It's that simple."
We disagree on this. They had the opportunity to do so and didn't because, as strange as it may seem to you, they want to rule on the case.

You write "Go to Yahoo and put in the words 'Supreme Court sends case back to lower court" That is NOT what we were discussing and will give false responses. I have acknowledged that the court CAN kick back a case once oral arguments have been herd but that they have never done so. It is you that insists that they HAVE done so and that puts the burden of proof on you.

So I will re-state: Please name for me one case where SCOTUS has herd oral argument and THEN sent it back down to the lower court. I doubt that you will because I doubt that there is one.