Reply #41: Now I see where your problem is with this. [View All]

[beevul]

"Nonetheless, it says exactly the same thing: that the ONLY action being proposed by Miller in order to "get" the bad, bad people is to ... do something ... to good, decent folks."


It describes no other actions outside the issue in question. It does not say that miller has done nothing else. It does not say that miller has proposed nothing else.

It says that THIS action proposed by miller is perfectly portrayed by the cartoon, and if in an effort to stay on this specific issue, you were to see it in that context, you might have to admit that its right on the money.


Here, maybe you can better understand a correction in your own wording, than you can mine from scratch:

Nonetheless, it says that the ONLY action being proposed by Miller where this specific proposal is concerned, in order to "get" the bad, bad people is to ... do something ... to good, decent folks.

There ya go. Now its spot on.

On edit: That you have to portray the cartoon as addressing something it was never meant to address in order to to attack it, should tell you something.