Reply #30: Isn't it different to require a drivers license, etc. to drive and an ID to walk or go jogging? [View All]

[pampango]

If I want to build a garage, I know I have to get a permit and other things from my local government. My neighbors and fellow residents have some interest in what I do with my property.

If I wish to drive, I understand I have to respect society's need to know that drivers are qualified (age, knowledge, vision, etc.) and have insurance to pay for my mistakes. I'm driving a 2,000 pound machine that can do a lot of damage to other people.

To me the question is not whether there are not some situations, like those you mentioned, when you should be legitimately expected to show your "papers", but whether we should have to show our "papers" in all situations - sitting in my living room, walking to the store, jogging on the bike path, hiking in the local nature reserve, etc. I, for one, am not so used to showing my papers that I wouldn't consciously notice it if the police stopped me while I was jogging and asked for my ID.