Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Nanjeanne

(4,961 posts)
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 09:01 AM Mar 21

If Gaza's Children Starve, Israel Will Lose Its Moral Legitimacy Forever [View all]

By David Rothkopf, a former senior U.S. government official and the author of ten books on foreign policy and politics.

The fighting in Gaza must stop. Not tomorrow. Today.
All available resources must immediately be directed to stopping the unprecedented famine that is underway in that embattled sliver of land that has already seen unspeakable suffering. As bad as the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7 was, the people and government of Israel must now recognize that today not just the country's security but its legitimacy are at stake as never before.


SNIP

Former USAID Administrator Gayle Smith told me, "We are already seeing death by starvation and are looking at an accelerating trajectory towards famine from now through May and likely catastrophic famine by July."


Jeremy Konyndyk, president of Refugees International, said, "When children begin dying of evident starvation, as we're now seeing, that is indicative of extreme, sustained deprivation. Given the overwhelming levels of food deprivation and rapidly accelerating malnutrition in the latest reporting (doubled since January), this famine is building momentum very rapidly.
"There will a lot of kids right now who are at the level of advanced malnutrition that the dying kids were approximately four weeks ago. The numbers will keep rising until something major changes the trajectory."


Snip

If the race to avert catastrophic famine is lost," she states, it will not be the fault of aid groups: Responsibility should be laid firmly at the feet of the politicians whose responsibility it is to create such conditions.

That means, first and foremost, the Israeli government. But it also means all the nations of the world who are in a position to help, right now. The blame-shifting and inflamed rhetoric and political posturing and disastrous decision-making that have brought us to this awful point must stop. Fundamental decency requires it.
But so too does the recognition that the failure to effectively intervene now to end the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza will be a moral stain on the reputation of Israel from which the country may never recover.


Read Haaretz subscribers [link:https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-03-21/ty-article-opinion/.premium/if-gazas-children-starve-israel-will-lose-its-moral-legitimacy-forever/0000018e-5c96-d3c4-a7cf-7dd6e7720000|]

Read Free Link [link:https://archive.is/KXavj|]
68 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I think we are past "if they starve". SYFROYH Mar 21 #1
We might be past edhopper Mar 21 #2
In my mind, they have already lost that moral legitimacy. lastlib Mar 21 #5
I completely agree. liberalla Mar 21 #22
Yes true - but what will happen is even worse. The article's facts and figures are staggering. Nanjeanne Mar 21 #3
I am not sure how this is happening with so much food aide going into Gaza. jimfields33 Mar 21 #27
It's hard to deliver supplies in an active war zone. cab67 Mar 21 #42
Israel restricts the aid. For instance, scissors are "dual use", so they turned away truck with them in medical supplies muriel_volestrangler Mar 21 #54
This message was self-deleted by its author Avalon Sparks Mar 21 #57
It isn't very much food going in. I read today that before the war, 500 trucks a day DemocraticPatriot Mar 21 #59
I'm curious how this is "unprecedented" EX500rider Mar 21 #4
Its unprecedented for people that live in the shelter of the U.S. nt LexVegas Mar 21 #6
sort of. cab67 Mar 21 #43
All part of the antisemitic narrative Zeitghost Mar 21 #8
Anti-starvation is not antisemitism. ramen Mar 21 #13
Yes, being anti-cruelty and starvation has nothing to do with PatSeg Mar 21 #31
How is starving kids in Gaza "the antisemitic narrative"? obamanut2012 Mar 21 #18
I don't see a link between the two either. Dave Bowman Mar 21 #28
The amount of bullshit like this, "speaking out against the starvation of kids means you hate Jews" is Sky Jewels Mar 21 #39
When did I make the claim that it was? Zeitghost Mar 21 #55
What Avalon Sparks Mar 21 #19
Oh Please.... Nutty Putty Mar 21 #34
The war and starvation in Sudan is another humanitarian crisis that is staggering. Humanitarian Nanjeanne Mar 21 #10
Our allies are supposed to better. IMO: Israel had/has become our bullying little TeamProg Mar 21 #14
The US isn't shipping weapons to Sudan on an emergency basis. David__77 Mar 21 #20
" simply because aid is not allowed in by Israel." EX500rider Mar 21 #56
Please provide a link for 140 trucks per day. Previously someone gave some indormation Nanjeanne Mar 21 #58
How about the UN? EX500rider Mar 21 #61
The situation is appalling. Every minute, every hour, it is getting worse," Nanjeanne Mar 21 #62
You said "simply because aid is not allowed in by Israel." I said up to 140+ aid trucks have been arriving every day EX500rider Mar 21 #64
Okey dokey. A distribution problem. Got it. Cogat says lots of trucks!!!! Nanjeanne Mar 21 #68
Israel has now lost all moral legitimacy for me. Lonestarblue Mar 21 #7
Uh. I think it's the recent slaughter of a generation of Israeli's in the 1940's that allows them to finally jimfields33 Mar 21 #29
So because shitty things were done to them, they get to Cuthbert Allgood Mar 21 #60
There no rationalizing with Hamas. jimfields33 Mar 21 #66
Well past that point. Autumn Mar 21 #9
History will not be kind. nt TeamProg Mar 21 #11
Moral what? malaise Mar 21 #12
I wonder if anyone remembers how Israel came to be. Zilli Mar 21 #15
That version of history is not correct. Prior to the British Mandate the Ottoman Empire had complete control over that JohnSJ Mar 21 #23
President Truman was BlueMTexpat Mar 21 #24
I sincerely hope that Mr. Lucy didn't have a long "teaching" career. Google could have really helped him out, or, if TeamProg Mar 21 #45
The Brits have been stealing other people's land for centuries malaise Mar 21 #52
They lost legitimacy when Bosnia slaughtered Muslims in the 80s RainCaster Mar 21 #16
Apparently, "never again" does not apply to Palestinians. Earth-shine Mar 21 #17
Ridiculous twisting. TheKentuckian Mar 21 #47
"Never again" needs to apply to everyone. Earth-shine Mar 21 #48
Actually, Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Jews BlueMTexpat Mar 21 #21
There's a reason Bill Clinton never used the word "genocide" in the context of Bosnia or Rwanda. cab67 Mar 21 #44
They already have been. That train has long left the station. onecaliberal Mar 21 #25
In my heart they already did that. flying_wahini Mar 21 #26
In reality as well. onecaliberal Mar 21 #33
Israel is becoming a pariah state... Dave Bowman Mar 21 #30
Both sides claim to have God on their side and believe that killing each other is righteous. Ping Tung Mar 21 #32
Or better yet, stop believing in non-existent magical beings Sky Jewels Mar 21 #36
I've never undertood why people would select a God that requires that they "fear" it. Ping Tung Mar 21 #40
Right. Sky Jewels Mar 21 #46
Few religious people "select" their gods. Mariana Mar 21 #50
I was born a Roman Catholic but not baptized. Ping Tung Mar 21 #53
This message was self-deleted by its author Avalon Sparks Mar 21 #63
They don't believe in the same God JI7 Mar 21 #65
OK. If they're not the same god which one is the One True God? Ping Tung Mar 21 #67
"If" they starve? TOO LATE. Many are starving. Some have died from it. Sky Jewels Mar 21 #35
Europe had restricted Jewish people to ghettoes back in the day IronLionZion Mar 21 #37
Israel will ForgedCrank Mar 21 #38
"People keep falling for it" Sympthsical Mar 21 #49
Gaza is being turned to rubble -- and Jared Kushner thinks its waterfront is a 'very valuable' real-estate prospect SARose Mar 21 #41
"Moral Legitimacy" is not something Nation-States possess. maxsolomon Mar 21 #51
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»If Gaza's Children Starve...