Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

AloeVera

(2,133 posts)
133. A peaceful and prosperous future for all is the hope, of course, but how to get there now?
Mon Jul 29, 2024, 10:58 PM
Jul 2024

You could say that the Abraham Accords in some ways led to October 7th. It's a harsh view, I know, but it's shared by many and it's not far-fetched. It gave nothing to Palestinians except some vague promise that Israel would endeavour towards a solution. Which didn't happen. The Accords not just sidelined the Palestinian issue but made it pretty much invisible and forgotten. It was the despair and anger, the sense of betrayal too, that fomented the necessary hatred to carry out October 7th.

In fact even the the State Department under Trump warned that the Accords and the normalization were leading to further radicalization of terrorist groups. No one listened, right up to October 7th.

And now the Knesset has essentially outlawed a 2-state solution. So what is there left? Is Israel willing to give ANYTHING to Palestinians?

And why is the cycle of violence pre-destined? Are you saying that nothing is going to change either in Israel's policies or Palestinians' rage and despair? It's not an equal fight, it has not been for nearly 50 years, you could say more. Might makes right in this world and that will always lead to resistance and efforts to re-balance towards some justice.

As for the WWII analogies, I don't buy that. There is not a shred of commonality with the circumstances of Palestinians. Germans and Japanese were clearly the agressors, annexed illegally in the case of Germany, had their own nation-state to begin with, they were not expelled from their homeland and barred from returning (Berlin Wall notwithstanding), their occupation by the Allies was time-limited and they had the Marshall Plan. "Befriending" and showing compassion and humanity, giving vast financial assistance for reconstruction to your former enemies - all of this goes a long way toward healing and reconciliation. Is Israel willing to do that now?

I have seen a lot of that "why are they not like Germans, why can't they just let bygones be bygones like civilized people"? It's absurd to me that those arguing this don't see they are comparing apples and oranges and then blaming Palestinians for not being the right kind of fruit. Or rotten fruit, because they just won't accept that they've been plucked and plundered like "civilized" people.

And yes, I do see subtle Islamophobia and racism at work in these types of arguments. Similar to how you see suppressed anti-Semitism bubbling to the surface in people who are very vocal in their criticism of Israel.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Per usual, intentionally attacking civilians. So they'll get whatever they get. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #1
I'm afraid . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #3
Idf kills/ cripples more Palestinians than 30 every day questionseverything Jul 2024 #6
Using the Hamas run spurious numbers from the Health Ministry is a fools errand. SlimJimmy Jul 2024 #9
We see the bodies so it's not hard to believe the counts questionseverything Jul 2024 #13
Yet, you said "the IDF kills more everyday," so it's hard to accept you feel bad. AZLD4Candidate Jul 2024 #14
I'm not incorrect, the idf has killed/maimed more every day for the last 3/4 a year questionseverything Jul 2024 #15
So that gives license to kill Jewish children? Gotcha. AZLD4Candidate Jul 2024 #16
I never claimed anyone has a right to kill anyone questionseverything Jul 2024 #17
Hamas started this, they are holding Israeli hostages. Mosby Jul 2024 #22
There's only one side attacking in all that time? onandup Jul 2024 #88
I see. . .you realize Israel has taken more terrorist attacks than any other nation on Earth over the last 70 years AZLD4Candidate Jul 2024 #23
Would you assert that Israel is blameless in all of this? Orrex Jul 2024 #37
It is a WAR... PCIntern Jul 2024 #43
That excuse seems to be available for Israel but not for Palestinians. Orrex Jul 2024 #44
Yes It's WAR That GD HamasTerroists Started Begging Cha Jul 2024 #119
They literally dug up their dead to withdraw from Gaza and give it to the Palestinians NickB79 Jul 2024 #92
Please help me remember the name . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #97
You know that's an asinine question, right? Orrex Jul 2024 #106
You see what Hamas wants you to SlimJimmy Jul 2024 #111
Well, Hamas uses civilians as shields daily. And these civilians SUPPORT them oldsoftie Jul 2024 #19
You have no proof that 70% of Palestinians back Hamas questionseverything Jul 2024 #20
Of course I have proof; I dont post opinion as fact. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #21
That's not support for Hamas, or for Oct 7th atrocities. AloeVera Jul 2024 #28
From your source: Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #36
91% think Hamas did not commit atrocities on October 7. Nuff said. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #47
What I find hilarious is the suggestion that with 91% being ignorant of the atrocities, Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #55
Hadn't thought of that but great comparison. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #68
I'm very curious about polls Ghost of Tom Joad Jul 2024 #56
Excellent question (nt) Richard D Jul 2024 #81
I wondered too. It's laid out pretty clearly on the website. AloeVera Jul 2024 #99
Look at the election results they had in the ONE election they had. Hamas won 74/132 seats AZLD4Candidate Jul 2024 #24
2006 is a long time ago questionseverything Jul 2024 #25
Keep moving those goal posts. AZLD4Candidate Jul 2024 #26
How many Palestinians living today voted for Hamas in 2006? Orrex Jul 2024 #45
How many living today supported the attacks in Oct? Most of them. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #48
I know that it's important for you to believe that to support the narrative Orrex Jul 2024 #65
Accept Israels right to exist & start to live a better life. Their choice. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #67
You're asking the occupied population to tell other nations to embrace the occupiers. Orrex Jul 2024 #70
Jordan was part of the original partitioning why aren't THEY "occupiers"? oldsoftie Jul 2024 #71
Fair question. Orrex Jul 2024 #74
Who's calling for their total removal like the Palestinians do with Israel? oldsoftie Jul 2024 #101
You have little or nothing to contribute to this discussion. Orrex Jul 2024 #107
I only contribute facts; sorry you dont like them. Israel isnt going away oldsoftie Jul 2024 #108
Bullshit. See Posts #36 and 55. Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #82
See Postt #28. AloeVera Jul 2024 #30
It is not false. See Post #36 Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #42
Your own link proves you wrong. 91% dont think Hamas committed any atrocities in Oct. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #49
If you cite statistics, pls give the full picture. AloeVera Jul 2024 #59
Well, back at ya: if you cite statistics, please give the full picture. Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #76
Well said. I wish more here SlimJimmy Jul 2024 #112
Excuse me. This is a tragic day for Israel. jimfields33 Jul 2024 #27
Irony is dead. AloeVera Jul 2024 #110
Hezbollah Kills Scarlet Begalas Jul 2024 #105
of course!! nt oldsoftie Jul 2024 #18
Irony is dead. AloeVera Jul 2024 #62
Notes on this from a newsletter from Israel Richard D Jul 2024 #2
My God. AloeVera Jul 2024 #5
Post removed Post removed Jul 2024 #10
Have a nice day. AloeVera Jul 2024 #12
Post a link to the source, please. nt PufPuf23 Jul 2024 #35
It's from a Telegram newsletter from Israel . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #39
More question everything Jul 2024 #4
Of course they'd say that cabotnn22 Jul 2024 #7
Not to forget that the Druze represent a large number of officers in the IDF R Merm Jul 2024 #8
Exactly cabotnn22 Jul 2024 #11
From IDF Chief of Staff, Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #40
Irony is dead, buried and forgotten. AloeVera Jul 2024 #61
It could lead to a full war in Lebanon Meowmee Jul 2024 #29
This message was self-deleted by its author Skittles Jul 2024 #31
No need for a full war. The IDF likely knows where most terrorists & their weaponry are located oldsoftie Jul 2024 #51
It was probably because that tocket had such a short flight path Warpy Jul 2024 #32
Do we actually know that? AloeVera Jul 2024 #33
True, and one must never lose sight of the absolute fact . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #41
That is true as well. Never start a war. AloeVera Jul 2024 #63
Her skirt was too short Richard D Jul 2024 #69
That's the best you got? AloeVera Jul 2024 #72
Awful on purpose. Richard D Jul 2024 #75
I fail to see how you could have misunderstood. AloeVera Jul 2024 #83
Gaza or Hezbollah . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #87
You know as well as I.... AloeVera Jul 2024 #89
Thank you for this reply. Richard D Jul 2024 #93
Or maybe they are not antisemitic, but they have fallen for the lies of some antisemites. raging moderate Jul 2024 #104
Thank you as well. AloeVera Jul 2024 #121
Something to consider further: Orrex Jul 2024 #109
Something else to consider: Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #114
I don't understand your reply . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #123
Racists are usually the first ones to deny they are racist. Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #124
Got it Richard D Jul 2024 #125
Congrats on your 9000th post! Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #126
Oh wow! Richard D Jul 2024 #127
I'm going to frame this response. AloeVera Jul 2024 #122
Both have the same STATED goal; the TOTAL elimination of Israel. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #129
Then blame Hezbollah; who just started it after being warned NOT to. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #52
Of course not. N/T. AloeVera Jul 2024 #57
Spam deleted by MIR Team bidance Jul 2024 #58
A fact conveniently forgotten. AloeVera Jul 2024 #60
Israeli. Richard D Jul 2024 #115
I guess it doesn't really matter. I shouldn't have asked. AloeVera Jul 2024 #116
The entire country is mourning their deaths. (nt) Richard D Jul 2024 #118
Yes, of course!! AloeVera Jul 2024 #120
They DID attack Israel. Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #85
Considering how thick the propaganda is over there and from all sides Warpy Jul 2024 #91
Unlike Gaza Lebanon is large enough to get away from the fighting if you want to EX500rider Jul 2024 #94
Exactly this BrianTheEVGuy Jul 2024 #95
Exactly SlimJimmy Jul 2024 #113
Simply respond proportionately. AloeVera Jul 2024 #96
That's no way to end a war EX500rider Jul 2024 #98
Well, I'm not a war expert. AloeVera Jul 2024 #100
"Hasn't worked well in Gaza though." Actually it has EX500rider Jul 2024 #102
De-escalate. AloeVera Jul 2024 #117
On one hand, yeah . . . Richard D Jul 2024 #132
A peaceful and prosperous future for all is the hope, of course, but how to get there now? AloeVera Jul 2024 #133
Spam deleted by MIR Team bidance Jul 2024 #79
Welcome to DU....I guess. GP6971 Jul 2024 #80
In war, there are no winners. James48 Jul 2024 #34
Too many people playing the blame game currently. Aussie105 Jul 2024 #38
Message auto-removed Name removed Jul 2024 #46
I think you got that backwards. replace Israel with Hamas/hezbollah oldsoftie Jul 2024 #53
Spam deleted by MIR Team bidance Jul 2024 #54
Cant force you to accept facts; but they say it themselves. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #66
Post removed Post removed Jul 2024 #78
Spam deleted by MIR Team bidance Jul 2024 #50
You're wrong about that Hieronymus Phact Jul 2024 #73
Spam deleted by MIR Team bidance Jul 2024 #77
Nor how the international community sees it. AloeVera Jul 2024 #86
The international community sees it as a terrirory occupied by one belligerent state still at war with another Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #90
Thank you for that. Tough shit for the losers. oldsoftie Jul 2024 #103
Spam deleted by MIR Team bidance Jul 2024 #64
They're so bad a ground tactics that they've won every war they've been in. Swede Jul 2024 #84
And the endless cycle continues. yourout Jul 2024 #128
What happened HarryM Jul 2024 #130
What happened is it's not 100% perfect. maxsolomon Jul 2024 #131
For accuracy, the Druze children killed were Syrian citizens, not Israeli. Confirmed by local Druze authorities. AloeVera Jul 2024 #134
For accuracy, they were legal permanent residents of Israel. Do you want to hear the explanation again? Ok, here it is: Beastly Boy Jul 2024 #135
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»At least 6 killed (now 15...»Reply #133