Reply #16: djnn....since you have joined... [View All]

[pelsar]

for reasons that I cant understand Englander refuses to continue a discussion that he/she started with an article that he put up..

since you have joined in....lets see if you can:

The article prepares the ground work for condeming israel for attempting to stop kassams that may fall into israel after (theoritical) the pull out of Gaza

But even if Palestinian security forces fail in those duties, the wholesale demolition of many homes in response amounts to the collective punishment of civilians, which also violates international law

so since you have taken the initiative to join in I assume you dont have a problem with responding to the scenario?

the scenario is that Gaza is devoid of israelis (and the IDF), yet the PA, or whomever is in charge is not able or will not stop the kassams from flying into israel....

what realistic response from israel would you back up to "stop the rockets". A response where you would say: israel has the right to do.... and I back them up (if any..)

I have my own theories why Englander wont respond, and I will respond to any question you put forth (including the above)...but since the article was put up by a "pro palestenian" something you seem to identify with, I have responded to the initial article


limit your response to the actual question, later you can divert.

GO!